Somewhere in southeastern Oklahoma, tucked inside a small town most people drive right past, sits a market that genuinely stops you in your tracks. You walk in expecting a quick browse and walk out carrying a bag full of things you never knew you needed.
The aromas hit you first, followed by shelves packed with Italian imports, house-made cheeses, and a deli counter that regulars talk about for weeks. If you love discovering places that punch far above their weight, this one belongs on your Oklahoma road trip list.
Krebs, Oklahoma and the Little Italy of the Plains
Not every great food destination announces itself with neon signs and highway billboards. Krebs, Oklahoma sits quietly off Highway 69, a short five-minute drive from McAlester, and it carries a nickname that surprises first-time visitors: the Little Italy of Oklahoma.
The town has deep Italian immigrant roots stretching back generations, and that heritage shows up in its food culture more than almost anywhere else in the state.
Lovera’s Italian Market is one of the anchors of that identity, operating out of a charming two-story building that looks like it has been part of the neighborhood forever. Visitors making the drive from Tulsa, Bentonville, or Dallas often use it as a planned midpoint stop, not just a spontaneous detour.
The address places it at 95 NW 6th St, Krebs, OK, but regulars will tell you to simply follow your nose once you hit town.
Krebs itself rewards a slow wander. Pairing a stop at the market with a meal at one of the nearby Italian restaurants in town makes for a full afternoon worth planning around.
Oklahoma rarely surprises visitors this thoroughly in such a compact little corner of the state.
The Building and Its Old-School Charm
First impressions matter, and the building that houses this market earns its keep before you even open the door. Housed in a quaint old two-story structure, the exterior has a lived-in, familiar quality that feels more European village than small-town Oklahoma.
There is nothing flashy about it, and that is exactly the point.
Stepping inside feels like walking into a different era. One visitor described it as stepping back into childhood, comparing the atmosphere to a beloved small-town market from decades past.
The layout is compact but thoughtfully organized, fitting a remarkable variety of products into a space that never feels cluttered or overwhelming.
Wooden shelving, a deli counter toward the back, and the layered smell of cured meats, aged cheese, and imported spices all contribute to an atmosphere that chain grocery stores simply cannot replicate. Regulars mention that the store feels genuinely curated rather than assembled from a distributor catalog.
Every corner holds something worth picking up and reading, whether it is a jar of specialty sauce or a bag of pasta in a shape you have never seen before. The building quietly sets the tone for everything that follows inside it.
Generations of Family Ownership Behind the Counter
Family-owned businesses carry a certain energy that is hard to manufacture, and Lovera’s has been building that energy for a long time. Visitors who have been shopping here for over four decades speak to the consistency and care the family has maintained across the years.
That kind of loyalty from customers does not happen by accident.
The Lovera family’s commitment to quality shows up in the products they choose to stock and the recipes they use for their house-made items. Staff members are consistently described as friendly, helpful, and genuinely knowledgeable about what they sell.
First-time visitors are encouraged to mention it is their initial trip, since that often leads to samples of house-made cheese and sausage, a generous and welcoming tradition that reflects the market’s hospitality-first approach.
That personal touch extends to how the store handles customer feedback. When issues have arisen with orders, the ownership has responded directly and offered to make things right, demonstrating accountability that goes beyond a simple transaction.
Shoppers from across Oklahoma and neighboring states return not just for the products but for the feeling of being recognized and valued. In a retail landscape dominated by self-checkout kiosks, that human connection feels almost radical.
Italian Imports Packed onto Every Shelf
Browsing the shelves at Lovera’s is a slow, rewarding exercise in discovery. The selection of imported Italian goods covers far more ground than a standard grocery store ethnic aisle.
Specialty olive oils fill one section, with enough variety to make choosing genuinely difficult. Pasta comes in shapes that rarely appear on supermarket shelves, and the spice selection leans toward authentic Italian pantry staples rather than generic blends.
Visitors consistently mention finding things they had never seen locally before, products that previously required an online order or a trip to a major metro area. The joy of stumbling across a particular type of imported biscuit or a specialty jarred ingredient is exactly the kind of thing that turns a quick stop into a longer browse.
Many shoppers leave with far more than they originally planned to buy.
Pickled items, specialty breads, and Italian cookies round out the dry goods section, giving the market a depth that rewards repeat visits. Regulars note that each trip tends to surface something new, whether it is a seasonal item or a recently added import.
The store also stocks take-home and bake meal kits, including options like Chicken Parmigiana that shoppers have praised for generous portion sizes and authentic flavor once prepared at home.
House-Made Cheeses Worth the Drive Alone
Among everything the market offers, the house-made cheeses hold a special place in the loyalty of regular customers. Fresh cheese with the wax casing still intact is not something most Oklahoma shoppers encounter outside a specialty retailer, and the quality here draws consistent praise.
Visitors have described standing at the cheese counter struggling to choose because everything looked so appealing.
First-time shoppers who mention it is their initial visit are often offered samples, making the cheese counter an interactive and generous experience rather than a passive browse. The variety covers enough ground to satisfy both the casual cheese fan looking for something familiar and the more adventurous shopper seeking something less common in the regional market.
House-made cheese also appears as an ingredient in other products sold at the store, including sausages and prepared meal kits, giving the cheese program an influence that extends well beyond the deli counter. Regulars who camp at nearby Lake Eufaula have mentioned picking up cheeses to enjoy at the campsite, a detail that says something about how well the products travel and hold up.
For anyone who takes cheese seriously, this counter alone justifies rerouting a road trip through southeastern Oklahoma to make the stop.
Sausages and Cured Meats Made In-House
Meat lovers who wander into the market quickly realize they are not dealing with standard supermarket fare. House-made sausages sit alongside a selection of fresh cuts and cured meats that staff will slice to order, a service that feels increasingly rare in an era of pre-packaged everything.
The sausages in particular draw strong loyalty from repeat customers who make special trips just to stock up.
Visitors camping at area lakes have described grabbing Italian sausage to cook at the campsite, which speaks to both the quality and the versatility of what the market offers. The meat selection also includes fresh cuts that have earned praise for their quality, though some shoppers have noted that the fresh counter outperforms the frozen bundle boxes in terms of reliability.
Sampling the house-made sausage is one of the traditions for first-time visitors, making it an easy entry point into the market’s meat program. The staff behind the counter are knowledgeable about what they are selling and willing to walk new customers through the options.
For road-trippers with a cooler in the car, the cured meats and sausages make for excellent travel companions, easy to take home and enjoy long after the drive is done.
The Deli Counter and Sandwich Menu in the Back
Tucked toward the back of the store, the deli counter operates as the market’s most talked-about feature among visitors who have eaten there. A rotating sandwich menu offers both Italian-inspired options and some unexpected regional twists that reflect the market’s Oklahoma roots as much as its Italian heritage.
The counter is compact but productive, turning out orders that regulars describe with genuine enthusiasm.
Sandwiches are priced around ten dollars each, landing them firmly in the affordable lunch category for the quality and portion size delivered. The menu includes options built around Italian cold cuts and house-made ingredients, alongside heartier BBQ-influenced sandwiches featuring brisket, pulled pork, and pork loin on toasted flatbread.
That combination of Italian tradition and Oklahoma smokehouse sensibility is one of the more unexpected and satisfying things the market pulls off.
Outdoor seating is available on the side and back of the building, with shaded tables that make warm-weather lunches genuinely pleasant. When weather allows, eating outside adds a relaxed, unhurried quality to the visit.
Online ordering is also available through the market’s website, a convenience that regulars have noted as a useful option for planning ahead before making the trip down to Krebs.
The Bada Bing Sandwich and Why It Has a Following
Some menu items develop a reputation that travels faster than any advertisement could manage, and the Bada Bing sandwich at Lovera’s has become exactly that kind of cult favorite. Regulars name it as their automatic go-to order, returning for it visit after visit without needing to look at the rest of the menu.
The enthusiasm around it is specific and personal in a way that generic praise rarely is.
One visitor put it plainly: the Bada Bing was the most amazing sandwich they had ever eaten, and they suggested the market deserved national food television attention. That level of hyperbole from a satisfied customer tends to carry weight when it shows up repeatedly across different visits and different people.
The sandwich has clearly found its audience.
What makes a sandwich memorable enough to anchor repeat trips from across state lines? In this case, it comes down to the combination of quality house-made ingredients, the right bread, and a build that delivers something coherent rather than just a pile of toppings.
The Bada Bing benefits from everything the market does well, from its cured meats to its house-made components, assembled into something that feels deliberate and satisfying rather than accidental. For first-time visitors unsure where to start, this is the sandwich to order.
The Muffuletta and the Brisket Sandwich as Runner-Up Stars
Beyond the Bada Bing, two other sandwiches have built their own loyal followings among visitors who have worked their way through the menu. The muffuletta earns consistent praise for being generous enough to share, a detail worth knowing before ordering one solo.
Built with the layered Italian cold cuts and olive components that define the classic New Orleans-style sandwich, it delivers a satisfying combination of salt, richness, and texture.
The brisket sandwich occupies a different flavor lane entirely, leaning into Oklahoma’s BBQ tradition with slow-cooked brisket and a sweet-savory sauce served on toasted flatbread. Visitors who have tried both often describe the two as complementary rather than competing, each delivering a distinct experience.
Having both on the same menu reflects the market’s comfortable position at the intersection of Italian heritage and Oklahoma food culture.
Pulled pork and pork loin round out the BBQ-influenced side of the sandwich menu, giving meat-focused visitors plenty to work with across multiple visits. The price point, around ten dollars per sandwich, makes trying more than one option on a single trip a reasonable proposition.
Portions are described as generous, which adds to the overall value equation and helps explain why the sandwich counter draws visitors from well outside the immediate area.
Cannoli and Desserts That Land the Finishing Punch
Saving room for dessert at Lovera’s is not optional so much as inevitable. The cannoli in particular has earned the kind of praise that resets a person’s expectations for the pastry entirely.
One visitor described having tried cannoli at various places over the years and found them consistently average, only to have the version at this market become the best they had ever eaten. That is a meaningful claim from someone with a reference point for comparison.
Cannoli are filled to order upon request, which makes a genuine difference in texture. A cannoli shell that has been sitting pre-filled loses its crispness quickly, and the made-to-order approach preserves the contrast between the crunchy shell and the creamy filling that defines the pastry at its best.
Blueberry cheesecake has also appeared on the dessert offerings, drawing positive mentions from visitors who tried it alongside their sandwiches.
Italian cookies are available as well, with some appearing to be made in-house rather than imported, a distinction that attentive shoppers have picked up on and appreciated. The dessert selection ties the visit together as a complete experience rather than just a grocery run.
Leaving without something sweet feels like a missed opportunity, especially given how well the pastry program complements the rest of what the market does.
Sauces, Pasta, and Take-Home Meal Kits
Not every great find at Lovera’s gets eaten on-site. A significant part of the market’s appeal lies in what shoppers take home, and the house-made sauces and pasta selections are among the most popular items to pack into a bag for the road.
Marinara and pizza sauce made in-house have drawn praise from visitors who picked them up alongside fresh pasta and brought everything home to cook.
The take-home and bake meal kits add another layer of convenience for shoppers who want the Lovera’s experience without the drive back to Krebs every time. The Chicken Parmigiana kit has been specifically called out by visitors who cooked it at their campsites and found it delivered on the promise printed on the packaging.
When a product’s portion claim says it feeds four and actually does, that kind of honest sizing builds real trust.
Pasta shapes at the market extend well beyond the standard grocery store selection, with specialty varieties that give home cooks something genuinely new to work with. Combined with the house-made sauces, the pasta aisle turns a visit into a pantry restocking opportunity that can elevate weeknight cooking for weeks after the trip.
For anyone who cooks Italian food at home with any regularity, this section of the store is particularly worth a careful look.
Outdoor Seating, Atmosphere, and Who Fits Right In
Eating at Lovera’s does not require finding a table inside. The market offers outdoor seating on the side and back of the building, with shading over roughly eight patio tables that make the space genuinely comfortable during pleasant weather.
The setting has a relaxed, unhurried quality that suits a long lunch better than a quick bite, and the surrounding neighborhood adds a quiet, small-town backdrop to the meal.
The market draws a broad mix of visitors, from road-trippers using it as a highway midpoint stop to locals who treat it as a regular weekly errand. Families, campers heading to or from Lake Eufaula, and food enthusiasts making a dedicated day trip from cities like Tulsa all show up in the mix.
The atmosphere accommodates all of them without feeling overly specialized toward any one group.
Busy periods can make the store feel lively rather than crowded, a distinction that speaks to how well the layout manages foot traffic. The friendly staff contributes significantly to the atmosphere, keeping interactions warm and efficient without rushing anyone through their visit.
For solo travelers, couples, and families alike, the market strikes a tone that feels genuinely welcoming rather than performatively so. EBT cards are accepted for non-hot food items, broadening accessibility for local shoppers.
Hours, Prices, and How to Plan Your Visit
Planning a stop at Lovera’s takes minimal effort once you know the basics. The market is open Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., giving most visitors a comfortable window to arrive without rushing.
Sunday hours are shorter, running from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m., so weekend visitors planning a later arrival should keep that in mind and aim to get there before early afternoon.
Prices across the board are described as reasonable by the majority of shoppers who have commented on them. Sandwiches run around ten dollars each, house-made cheeses and sausages are priced accessibly, and the imported grocery items sit at price points that reflect specialty quality without being prohibitive.
The overall value equation is one of the reasons visitors from further away feel the drive is justified.
The market can be reached by phone at 918-423-2842, and online ordering is available through the website at loverasmarket.com for those who want to plan their purchase in advance. Located just five minutes off Highway 69 near McAlester, the market is an easy detour for anyone traveling between Oklahoma City, Tulsa, or points south toward Texas.
Bringing a cooler is a practical tip worth following, since the house-made meats and cheeses are worth taking home.
Share this story
