You can reach one of Idaho’s spectacular alpine lakes without hiking the entire trail. Mystic Saddle Ranch offers a full-day horseback ride to Alice Lake, taking visitors deep into the Sawtooth Wilderness on a challenging mountain route.
The adventure starts at Pettit Lake and follows trails with rocky sections, creek crossings, and views of the surrounding peaks. Experienced trail horses carry riders into the mountains, with time to enjoy Alice Lake before heading back.
This isn’t a typical hour-long horseback outing. The route covers approximately 12 miles round trip and requires a full day in the saddle.
Here’s what makes the trip different, what riders can expect, and what to know before booking.
Meet the Outfitter Behind the Ride
Mystic Saddle Ranch is a guided horseback outfitter based near Stanley, Idaho, in Custer County. Its corrals sit close to the Redfish Lake area, right at the edge of the Sawtooth Mountains.
The ranch runs a range of trail rides during the summer season. Some are short loops of about an hour and a half, while others are half-day or full-day trips into the high country.
The Alice Lake ride is one of the longer adventures on the list.
Hours on its listing show the office open from 9 AM to 5 PM daily during operating season. Riding in this region depends on snow and weather, so it makes sense to check the official website before planning a trip.
What catches my attention is how much country the ranch can reach. Bench Lakes, Marshall Lake, Little Redfish Lake, and Alice Lake all appear among its rides.
That variety helps first-timers and experienced riders find a good fit. Still, one destination stands out for anyone curious about how far a horse can take you into the Sawtooths, and that is the trail to Alice Lake.
Alice Lake Sits Deep in the Sawtooth Wilderness
High above the valley floor, Alice Lake rests in a basin ringed by jagged granite. It is one of the better-known lakes in the Sawtooth Wilderness, and for good reason.
Hikers usually reach it from the Pettit Lake trailhead, and the walk is long. The trail gains steady elevation as it follows a creek through forest and open slopes.
For many people, covering that distance on foot in one day feels like a lot.
A horse changes the math. The Mystic Saddle Ranch all-day ride starts at Pettit Lake and follows the trail up to Alice Lake, so riders can spend energy enjoying the scenery instead of counting steps.
The Sawtooth Wilderness is protected land with no roads, which explains why the lake feels so remote. Getting there means traveling the old-fashioned way, either on boots or on hooves.
I find that idea appealing in a world of easy parking lots. You earn the view here, even if your horse does most of the earning.
The real question is what the trip actually looks like from start to finish.
A Full Day From Saddle Up to Sunset
Plan on giving the whole day to this ride. One rider described leaving around 9 in the morning and getting back around 5 in the afternoon.
That schedule includes the climb, a long break at the lake, and the trip back down. Another group mentioned having about two hours to relax at Alice Lake before heading home.
Small groups seem to be the norm. One couple shared the trail with a single other pair plus their wrangler, which keeps the pace friendly and personal.
Time in the saddle adds up, so comfort matters. Wear sturdy shoes with a heel, long pants, and layers you can tie on or stash.
Sunscreen and a hat help too, since much of the route rises into open mountain terrain. Mornings in Stanley can start chilly even in summer, then warm quickly once the sun climbs.
I would also bring a small camera and a little patience. A long day on horseback rewards people who settle into a slow rhythm.
Of course, the horses carrying you deserve their own spotlight.
Sure-Footed Horses Handle the Rough Stuff
Rocky switchbacks and creek crossings sound tricky until you watch a seasoned trail horse step through them. The Alice Lake route asks a lot from its animals.
Riders who have made the trip describe horses that crossed rocks and water calmly. One group even mentioned a bit of thunder on the way back, and their horses stayed steady.
A horse owner who rode to Alice Lake twice called this trail one that needs thoroughly trained animals. She felt the ranch horses fit that job well.
Names come with personality here. Monty, Steve, Pancho, and a slightly sassy horse called Casper have all been mentioned by riders.
The staff also tries to match horses with riders. That matters on a long route, where a calm, well-paired horse can make a nervous rider feel far more relaxed.
I like that the ranch talks about caring for its herd. Healthy, rested horses are safer horses, and the climb to Alice Lake is no place for shortcuts.
A good horse is only half the team, though, since every ride also needs a guide.
Guides Who Bring the Trail to Life
Stories make the miles go faster. Guides at Mystic Saddle Ranch have a reputation for sharing local history and tales about the Stanley area along the way.
One longtime guide named John has led many Alice Lake rides, and riders often mention his storytelling. He even speaks German, which delighted at least one visitor.
Other guides, including Chaz, Summer, Cora, Logan, and Tia, also appear in rider comments. Their focus tends to land on safety, riding tips, and getting to know the group.
That kind of attention helps on a demanding trail. A good guide watches how each horse and rider are doing and adjusts the pace when needed.
Guides also know the landscape well. They can point out lakes, peaks, and stream valleys you might otherwise ride right past.
I would ask plenty of questions. Wranglers who spend their summers in the Sawtooths usually have a few favorite facts tucked into their saddlebags, figuratively speaking.
Learning about the place from someone who knows it adds meaning to every view. Speaking of saddlebags, the real ones carry something important for this trip.
Lunch Packed and Ready in Your Saddlebags
Nobody wants to climb a mountain hungry. On the Alice Lake ride, lunch is part of the plan, and riders have praised how thoughtfully it was put together.
Saddlebags come along too. They give you a handy spot for water, snacks, a jacket, and small personal items without wearing a heavy backpack.
Packing smart still helps. Bring a refillable water bottle, sunscreen, bug spray, and a light rain layer, since mountain weather can shift in the afternoon.
Keep things compact. Saddlebags have limited room, so leave bulky gear behind and stick to what you will truly use.
Eating beside a high alpine lake sounds like a fine reward for hours on the trail. I like the simplicity of a packed meal with granite peaks for company instead of tables and menus.
Children and adults alike tend to appreciate a good snack break, but this one comes with scenery. Enjoy it slowly.
After lunch, many riders have time left over at the water. What people do with those free hours might surprise you.
Free Time at the Water
Two hours at a mountain lake can be spent many ways. One couple described lunch, some fishing, a little hiking, and even a short nap.
That flexibility is part of the appeal. You can explore the shoreline, take photos, or simply sit and enjoy the quiet.
Anglers may want to bring compact fishing gear. Remember that Idaho requires a valid fishing license for anyone old enough to need one, so handle that before your trip.
Hikers can wander a bit around the basin. Just stay aware of your group and the time, since the ride back down follows a set schedule.
A nap might sound silly after so much sitting. Yet resting in fresh mountain air seems to be a popular choice.
I would probably split my break between photos and doing absolutely nothing. Places like Alice Lake reward stillness as much as activity.
Leave the area as clean as you found it. The wilderness stays beautiful because visitors pack out what they bring.
Once break ends, everyone saddles up for a descent with its own challenges.
Who Should Tackle This Ride
Honesty helps here. Riders have called the Alice Lake trip challenging but doable, and one experienced rider said it was not for the faint of heart.
The long day matters as much as the terrain. Hours in the saddle can leave legs and backs sore, especially for people who rarely ride.
Some past riding experience is a smart idea before choosing an all-day trip. If you are unsure, talk with the ranch staff, since guides know which rides suit different skill levels.
Fitness also plays a part. Riders need to balance on steep sections and stay alert for several hours.
None of this should scare anyone away. It just means planning honestly about what feels comfortable.
I respect an outfitter that makes the toughness clear. Matching the ride to the rider keeps both people and horses safer on mountain trails.
If Alice Lake sounds like too much for now, you are not out of luck. Mystic Saddle Ranch runs gentler rides that still show off the Sawtooths, and they make a good warm-up.
Shorter Rides Make a Smart Warm-Up
Families with kids as young as six have ridden with this ranch. One group of eleven, spanning ages six to 77, enjoyed a 1.5-hour trail ride together.
Those shorter rides head toward views of Redfish Lake and Little Redfish Lake. Riders have mentioned a mountaintop look over Redfish that makes a short outing feel rewarding.
The ranch has also used a ramp to help riders mount and dismount. That small detail can make a big difference for older guests or nervous beginners.
For a middle option, the half-day Bench Lakes ride climbs to a high lake in about four hours. One rider described it as roughly eight miles round trip with about 1,200 feet of elevation gain.
Full-day trips also include Marshall Lake, which offers wide views of the Sawtooths and the valley below.
I would treat a short ride as practice. It lets you learn how a ranch horse moves and how your body handles the saddle.
Once you feel confident, Alice Lake becomes a natural next goal. Booking ahead matters, though.
Planning Tips Before You Book
Summer gets busy around Stanley. Riders have recommended making a reservation ahead of time, since popular time slots can fill up.
Season matters too. Snow lingers in the high Sawtooths, so long rides like Alice Lake generally depend on summer trail conditions.
Wildfire smoke can sometimes affect views in late summer. One rider on the Bench Lakes trail mentioned haze, though horseback still felt like a good way to enjoy the wilderness.
Check weather before your trip. Afternoon storms can roll through the mountains, so bring a rain layer just in case.
Stanley sits at high elevation, so drink plenty of water the day before and the morning of your ride. Altitude can make people tire faster than expected.
Beyond trail rides, the ranch also offers guided hunts on horseback in the fall. That shows how well the team knows this rugged backcountry.
I would start by browsing the official website for current ride options. Then pick a date, pack light, and let the horses carry you toward one of the quietest lakes in Idaho.
Share this story
