A cinnamon bun with an unusual muffin-like shape has become one of the calling cards at My Cafe Buzz in Bellefonte. But this family-run café offers much more than its best-known baked treat.
The menu includes locally roasted coffee, breakfast sandwiches, smoothie bowls, fresh baked goods, and iced drinks made with coffee ice cubes so they do not become watered down. The café also doubles as a small shopping stop, with local art, gifts, glassware, and other items filling the space around the coffee counter.
Opened in May 2020, My Cafe Buzz sits near Talleyrand Park and Spring Creek, giving visitors an easy excuse to turn a coffee run into a longer stop in historic Bellefonte.
The Buzz Begins on West High Street
Here is the answer to the mystery: My Cafe Buzz sits at 325 W High St, Bellefonte, PA 16823, in Centre County, Pennsylvania. It opened on May 7, 2020, in a spot that once held another cafe.
Heather Lingle, a Bellefonte native, runs the place with help from family. Her parents had long hoped to own the building, and she had always dreamed of a coffee shop.
The two plans fit together nicely, with coffee on one side and ice cream on the other.
The timing was unusual. Opening during the pandemic gave the team a slow, gentle start with coffee, baked goods, and smoothies before breakfast and lunch joined the menu.
Most days you will spot Heather, her mother, or her aunt behind the counter. Wait until you see what the inside looks like, because it surprised me more than the address did.
A Sunny Room With a Beach State of Mind
Bright yellow paint greets you the second the door swings shut behind you. Heather replaced the old dark red look with a sunny palette, and the whole room feels lighter for it.
Plants sit on shelves, counters, and corners, which adds a tropical feel. Some guests describe the mood as mystical, and I can see why.
Knickknacks and glassware fill the spaces between tables, and nearly everything is for sale.
The seating is relaxed and varied. A few tables inside suit a quiet laptop session, and the whole room hums softly with chatter.
I settled in with a notebook and forgot to check the time.
Outside, Pennsylvania weather may be doing its own thing, but in here it always feels like a vacation morning. The coffee deserves its own spotlight, and it gets one next.
Cinnamon Buns With a Local Reputation
Ask around Bellefonte and the cinnamon bun comes up before anything else. The cafe jokes that the buns are famous, and they are baked fresh throughout the day.
The shape leans more muffin than swirl. Many guests describe them as soft, gooey, and fluffy rather than heavy on cinnamon.
Heather has a tip, too: warm one up before eating it.
Opinions vary, as they do with any food. Some folks call it the best they have ever tasted, while others prefer a different style of bun.
That honesty is part of the fun.
I took one to go and followed her advice. A short stint in a warm oven turned the icing glossy and the center tender.
Half of mine disappeared before I reached the car, and the rest did not last long either. The cabinet holds more than buns, though.
Coffee With Local Roots and Clever Ice
Coffee here comes from Standing Stone Coffee Company in Huntingdon, a Pennsylvania roaster. Keeping the supply regional means fresher beans and a link to nearby businesses.
The menu covers espresso, cappuccino, Americano, macchiato, and pour-over. A dirty chai adds an espresso shot to a spiced latte, and the Cuban Affogato pairs bold espresso with coffee ice cream.
My favorite detail is the ice. Iced coffees and lattes use coffee ice cubes, so the drink never turns thin as it melts.
That small touch means the last sip tastes as good as the first.
Flavored lattes and drip coffee with maple also earn happy comments. Tea, hot chocolate, and smoothies cover anyone skipping caffeine.
I tried a fruity latte and a standard drip, and both arrived quickly. Hungry yet?
The next stop is the kitchen.
Breakfast Plates That Mix Sweet and Savory
Breakfast sandwiches arrive on toasted bagels, and they come with plenty of butter. That extra richness adds flavor, and guests keep praising the bacon, egg, and cheese version.
The Tiny Nato Sandwich stacks a French toast style bagel with maple syrup, ham, eggs, and cheese. It tastes like pancakes and a diner meal got along.
The Bit of Breakfast Plate offers eggs, a meat choice, and fruit or a bagel.
For lunch, the QMan Sandwich adds pork, ham, pickle, and spicy mustard. The Caboose piles egg and pulled pork with Carolina BBQ sauce onto a bagel.
Grilled cheese and soft pretzels keep things simple, and a jalapeño cheese pretzel adds a little kick.
I went with the sausage, egg, and cheese and finished every crumb. A lighter option waits next, and it looks like art.
Acai Bowls and Smoothie Bowl Surprises
Bowls here come thick, cold, and topped like small works of art. Pureed acai forms the base, then granola, fresh fruit, honey, and chocolate drizzle finish the job.
You can pick classic acai, mango, or mocha versions. One guest enjoyed a banana and peanut butter bowl and called it very filling, which matches my own experience with these portions.
Smoothies share the menu, and some drinkers note that they run a little icy. If you prefer a creamier texture, a bowl may suit you better.
Heather leans toward healthy choices, so lighter options fit right in.
I ate mine slowly, scooping a bit of everything into each bite. It felt like dessert but left me ready for a walk.
Speaking of walks, the next stop is a short one.
The Bakery Case Beyond the Buns
Peek past the cinnamon buns and the case keeps delivering. Peanut butter cookies, oatmeal cookies, and chocolate chip cookies sit beside playful items like mermaid sugar cookies.
Pineapple rum cupcakes have appeared on the list as well, though I would check what is available on the day you visit. Baked goods are made fresh each day by Heather and her mother.
Gluten-free fans have real choices. Protein bites come in daily flavors, and gluten-free chocolate drops sit nearby.
Peanut butter protein balls made a great snack for bike riders who stopped in from State College.
Ice cream comes from Ritchey’s Dairy in Martinsburg, which makes a cone a fine side trip. I left with a bag of cookies and zero regrets.
The shelves in the front room hold even more temptation.
Shopping Between Sips
Plan a little extra time, because the retail corner here is easy to get lost in. Shelves hold local art, crafts, stationery, mugs, honey, and vintage glassware.
A bee mug and infused honey made it home with one guest, and another picked up hand lotion and a gift for a friend. Heather says new items arrive often, so a second visit rarely looks like the first.
Local artists can show work on the walls too. That gives the cafe a gallery feel, and it helps creative neighbors reach new fans.
Some past vendors say they find something new to love on every trip.
I bought a mug and talked myself out of three other things. The gift options suit birthdays, thank-yous, and treat-yourself days.
Next, let us step outside into the setting around the building.
Tables by Talleyrand Park and Spring Creek
The setting around My Cafe Buzz is a big part of its appeal. The cafe sits near Talleyrand Park and Spring Creek, putting green space and water within easy reach of a coffee stop.
Outdoor seating gives customers a chance to enjoy that setting when Pennsylvania weather cooperates.
For someone arriving with a coffee and pastry, the nearby park also provides an easy place to continue the morning rather than immediately getting back into the car.
Spring Creek adds another dimension to the area. The waterway is well known among fly-fishing enthusiasts, making it more than simply a scenic creek running through town.
Dogs are welcome in the cafe’s outdoor area according to the original account, which can make the location especially convenient for people combining a walk with breakfast or coffee.
The park setting also creates a natural follow-up to a larger meal. Instead of ending the visit at the cafe door, diners can take a walk through the surrounding area.
Nearby attractions include Veterans Bridge and Bellefonte Railroad Historical Park, giving visitors several things to see within the same general part of town.
That makes My Cafe Buzz particularly easy to work into a longer Bellefonte outing. Coffee can be the starting point rather than the entire trip.
And once you begin walking, the historic character of Bellefonte quickly becomes another part of the experience.
Victorian Streets Just Outside the Door
Bellefonte gives visitors plenty to explore after breakfast or coffee. Its historic streets are filled with architecture that reflects the town’s long history.
The community is associated with the nickname “Central Pennsylvania’s Victorian Secret,” and its older buildings help explain why.
Decorative details, historic homes, brick buildings, and ironwork give downtown a noticeably different appearance from a modern shopping district.
Bellefonte was founded in 1795. During the 19th century, industries including iron and limestone, along with the arrival and expansion of rail transportation, played important roles in its development.
The town also has an unusual political connection. The article notes that Bellefonte has been home to seven governors representing three different states.
Today, downtown lends itself to exploring on foot. Boutiques, antique shops, and art galleries give visitors reasons to continue walking after leaving the cafe.
That makes a stop at My Cafe Buzz easy to combine with sightseeing. A morning coffee can become the beginning of several hours spent exploring downtown rather than a quick stop on the way somewhere else.
The historic surroundings also complement the cafe’s independent personality. Both offer something more individual than the standardized experience found along a typical commercial strip.
Still, the cafe’s identity ultimately comes back to the family behind the counter.
Heather’s Plan to Be Remembered
Heather Lingle’s goal is simple: she wants customers to leave happy and feel remembered when they return. That personal approach fits a cafe where family members are regularly involved in the business.
My Cafe Buzz is female-owned and family-run, and Heather’s mother and aunt have both helped behind the counter. The family connection has been part of the cafe’s identity since it opened.
Heather has also talked about bringing more family activities to the cafe, including sip-and-paint events, children’s crafts, and games. Those ideas could make the space as much about gathering as grabbing coffee.
The cafe’s phone number is 814-738-3843, and additional information is available through mycafe.buzz. Since hours and events can change, checking with the cafe before making a special trip is a good idea.
Between its coffee, baked goods, breakfast options, small retail area, and location near Talleyrand Park, My Cafe Buzz gives visitors several reasons to linger instead of simply grabbing a drink and leaving.
Share this story
