There is a sandwich shop in South Carolina where the subs are so loaded and so long that you genuinely cannot hold one with a single hand. People drive more than 25 minutes just to get there on a regular basis, and some make the trip every single week.
The bread has a crunchy crust with a soft center, the meats are piled high, and the mozzarella is made fresh in-house every day. Once you find out what is waiting at Nonna’s Italian Deli and Specialties in Summerville, you will completely understand why locals refuse to stop talking about it.
A Deli Unlike Anything Else on South Main Street
Some storefronts just pull you in before you even know what is inside. Nonna’s Italian Deli and Specialties sits at 129 S Main St, Summerville, SC 29483, right in the heart of downtown Summerville.
The moment you walk through the door, the atmosphere shifts completely.
There are no heat lamps. There are no microwaves.
Everything you see behind the counter was made that day, from the pasta salads to the pastries to the fresh mozzarella sitting in the display case.
Owner Rick has built something that feels genuinely personal here, the kind of place where he will personally walk you through the menu, share the story behind the business, and hand you a sample before you even place your order. That kind of care is rare, and it shows in every single detail of the experience.
The Italian Sub That Started Every Conversation
The Italian sub at Nonna’s is the sandwich that keeps coming up in every conversation about this place. It is stuffed with fresh, quality meats and layered with toppings that actually taste like something.
The bread has that classic Italian bakery quality: crunchy on the outside, soft and airy on the inside.
One half of a full sandwich is reportedly the size of your head. That is not an exaggeration.
Regulars frequently split a single sandwich between two people and still leave completely full.
What sets this sub apart from anything you might grab at a chain is the freshness of every single component. The meats are real, the mozzarella is house-made, and the bread holds everything together without falling apart.
This is the sandwich that earns Nonna’s its reputation, and it delivers every time someone new walks through the door.
The Dean Martin: A Sandwich With Its Own Fan Club
If there is one sandwich on the menu that people order before they even finish reading the rest of the board, it is the Dean Martin. The moment customers spot it listed, they stop looking.
It features a chicken cutlet soaked in vodka sauce, and the flavor combination is the kind that stays with you long after the last bite.
Multiple visitors have described ordering it immediately upon arrival and then spending the rest of their visit regretting that they did not leave room to try something else. That is a very good problem to have.
The Dean Martin has built something of an informal fan club among regulars. It comes up repeatedly as a first recommendation whenever someone asks what to order.
For a first visit to Nonna’s, it is hard to argue against starting with the sandwich that keeps drawing people back week after week.
Fresh Mozzarella Made Every Single Day
Rick makes fresh mozzarella in-house every single day. That detail alone separates Nonna’s from most delis you will encounter anywhere in the South.
Fresh mozzarella has a soft, milky, slightly springy texture that packaged versions simply cannot replicate, and the difference is immediately obvious the first time you taste it.
Customers who have been offered a sample of the fresh mozzarella consistently describe it as one of the most memorable bites of their visit. It is creamy without being heavy, and it pairs beautifully with the cured meats and bread that make up the deli’s sandwiches.
For anyone who grew up eating real Italian food or spent time in places like New York or New Jersey, this mozzarella triggers genuine nostalgia. For everyone else, it is simply a revelation.
Either way, accepting a sample when it is offered is absolutely the right move.
The Sinatra, the Hoboken, and the Art of Naming Sandwiches
Nonna’s takes a very particular approach to naming its sandwiches, and that approach says a lot about the personality of the place. The Sinatra comes loaded with sopressata, mortadella, and salami, finished with fresh mozzarella and a light kick that balances everything out perfectly.
The Hoboken is built around fresh roast beef and mozzarella, offering a hearty, filling option for anyone who prefers something more classic. The Mediterranean skips the meat entirely in favor of grilled vegetables and melted mozzarella, and it is genuinely satisfying for anyone who thinks a vegetarian sandwich cannot hold its own.
Each sandwich name carries a little bit of Italian-American culture with it. There is something fun about ordering a Sinatra or a Dean Martin, and the food behind those names earns the references.
These are not gimmicky titles slapped on ordinary sandwiches. Each one is built with real intention and real ingredients.
Pastries and Desserts That Deserve Their Own Visit
Nonna’s has a pastry chef on site, and the dessert case reflects that level of commitment. Cannoli, rainbow cookies, rum cake, key lime tarts, chocolate cherry tarts, pecan gooey bars, and blueberry lemon cheesecake are just some of the options that have earned enthusiastic reactions from first-time visitors.
The desserts here are not aggressively sweet. They are balanced, which is a quality that sets them apart from most bakery items you will find at a casual deli.
The Italian rum cake and the small S-shaped cookies are frequently mentioned as standout favorites, and the key lime tart has been described as having a perfect balance of sweet and tart with a bright citrus finish.
Even if you come in just for a sandwich, it is worth budgeting a few extra minutes to look through the dessert case. Leaving without at least one pastry is a decision most people seem to regret.
Ingredients Sourced With Genuine Intention
Rick is deliberate about where his ingredients come from. Olives are imported from Italy and Greece.
Some specialty items are sourced directly from New York, which is a detail that resonates strongly with customers who grew up eating real Italian-American food.
That kind of sourcing is not cheap and it is not easy, but it explains why the food at Nonna’s tastes different from what most people find at a typical deli. You can taste the difference between an ingredient chosen for quality and one chosen for convenience, and at Nonna’s, quality consistently wins.
The commitment to sourcing extends to the pasta, the sauces, the meats, and the cheeses throughout the menu. Nothing here feels like a shortcut.
Every component is chosen with the finished dish in mind, and that philosophy comes through clearly in the flavor of everything that comes out of this kitchen.
Grab-and-Go Italian Staples Worth Taking Home
Beyond the made-to-order sandwiches and pastries, Nonna’s stocks a solid selection of refrigerated and frozen items that you can grab and take home to cook yourself. Handmade pasta noodles, fresh sauces, and prepared meats are among the options available for anyone who wants to bring a piece of the deli experience into their own kitchen.
The pasta salads in the display case have their own following. The orzo salad has been mentioned specifically as a standout, and the chicken pasta salad has earned repeat purchases from customers who discovered it during their first visit.
For anyone who entertains regularly or just wants a quality weeknight dinner without starting from scratch, these take-home options are a practical and genuinely delicious solution. It is the kind of selection you would expect from a specialty Italian market, not a small-town deli, and that contrast is a big part of what makes Nonna’s so surprising.
Meatballs, Sausage, and the Comfort Food Side of the Menu
The sandwiches get most of the attention, but the savory sides at Nonna’s are worth talking about on their own. The meatballs are tender and well-seasoned, served with sauce in a way that makes them work beautifully both at the deli and reheated at home later that evening.
Rick personally walks customers through how to heat the meatballs properly so they stay tender rather than drying out. That kind of attention to the experience beyond the counter is something you notice at Nonna’s and do not find at most places.
The hot sausage with onions and peppers brings a satisfying warmth without crossing into overwhelming heat territory. It is the kind of dish that feels like a home-cooked meal rather than deli takeout.
For anyone craving something hearty and deeply satisfying, this side of the menu is well worth exploring alongside whatever sandwich you ordered.
The Cannoli Situation at Nonna’s
Cannoli come up frequently enough in conversations about Nonna’s that they deserve their own mention. A proper cannoli requires a crispy shell and a filling that is creamy without being runny, and getting that balance right consistently is harder than it looks.
Nonna’s cannoli have developed a loyal following among customers who know what a good cannoli should taste like. For transplants from the Northeast who spent years tracking down the real thing, finding quality cannoli in Summerville, South Carolina is genuinely exciting.
The cannoli are part of a broader dessert program that reflects the same philosophy as the rest of the menu: use good ingredients, make things properly, and do not cut corners. Whether you are a cannoli purist or trying one for the first time, this is a solid place to start.
They are listed among the most frequently mentioned items on the entire menu for a reason.
Why Transplants From the Northeast Keep Coming Back
There is a specific kind of homesickness that hits people who grew up eating real Italian-American food in places like New York, New Jersey, or Vermont, and then moved somewhere in the South where that food is nearly impossible to find. Nonna’s addresses that gap in a way that feels completely genuine.
One customer who relocated from Vermont now makes the 25-minute drive to Nonna’s once a week. Another visitor from New Jersey recognized something familiar before even stepping inside.
These are not people who are easily impressed by Italian food, because they have a real reference point for what it should taste like.
The fact that Nonna’s consistently earns that kind of loyalty from people who grew up with authentic Italian food says something important about the quality of what is being served. It is not a Southern interpretation of Italian food.
It is the real thing, and regulars can taste the difference.
Hours, Location, and What to Know Before You Go
Nonna’s is open Tuesday through Saturday from 10 AM to 6 PM. It is closed on Sundays and Mondays, so planning ahead matters if you want to make the trip count.
The deli sits at 129 S Main St in Summerville, right in the downtown area where parking is generally straightforward.
Seating inside is limited to one table, so most people order to go. The park across the street is a popular spot to eat on a nice day, which turns the whole outing into something a little more relaxed and enjoyable than a typical lunch run.
Arriving early is a smart move, especially on Saturdays when the deli tends to be busiest. The menu is large enough that a little extra time to look everything over is genuinely useful.
First-timers who try to rush through the experience tend to leave wishing they had taken more time to explore.
A Deli That Earns Its Reputation One Sandwich at a Time
Nonna’s Italian Deli and Specialties is the kind of place that quietly builds a reputation through consistency, quality, and the kind of hospitality that makes people feel like they matter. It does not need flashy marketing.
Word of mouth has been doing the work, and the crowds on a Saturday afternoon are proof that it is working.
Rick’s commitment to making everything fresh, sourcing quality ingredients, and treating every customer like a guest in his home creates an experience that is genuinely hard to find. The food earns the praise, and the atmosphere keeps people coming back even when they live far away.
If you find yourself anywhere near Summerville, stopping at Nonna’s is one of those decisions you will not second-guess afterward. Come hungry, plan to take your time, and consider bringing a friend, because one half of a sandwich might just be more than enough for one person on its own.
Share this story
