Two sacks. That’s how many fried pies one happy driver hauled home after a simple search led to a tiny shop on a quiet Tennessee street.
I love that the story starts with a phone search and ends with paper bags full of pastry.
The flavors alone make my stomach growl. Coconut lemon.
Amish peanut butter. Blueberry cream cheese.
Black raspberry. Pecan, too, folded into a half-moon of dough and fried until golden.
What gets me most is where these treats hide. Some sit inside a 1910 barn.
Others share shelves with bulk flour, local butter, and jars of jam. A few keep weekday-only hours, so timing matters.
I can’t think of a better excuse for a back-road drive. So which of these little counters deserves the first stop on your next Tennessee weekend, and how many pies will make it home?
1. Lynnville Fried Pie Company
Few businesses put their whole mission right in the name, and Lynnville Fried Pie Company does exactly that. You know what you came for before the door even swings open.
The shop sits on Mill Street in Lynnville, a small Giles County town south of Nashville. It’s an easy detour for anyone rolling through Middle Tennessee with a sweet tooth and a free afternoon.
Here, the stars are called Tennessee Turnovers. Flavors include chocolate, cherry, apple, peach, coconut lemon, blueberry, and apricot, so picking just one feels a little unfair.
Coconut lemon is the curveball worth noticing. It’s the kind of flavor that makes you rethink what a fried pie can be.
Need something savory first? A short menu of sandwiches gives you a reason to sit for a bit, and there’s plenty of seating inside the fun little store.
Coffee is available too. That pairing with a warm chocolate turnover sounds like a very good decision.
Plenty of folks treat this place as a stock-up stop. Loading up on pies to take home is part of the ritual, and nobody here will judge your second bag.
Prices stay friendly, which makes buying for the whole family painless. Your freezer might ask questions later.
Plan around the schedule, because the shop opens Tuesday through Saturday from 10 AM to 4 PM. Mondays and Sundays are closed, so a lazy Sunday craving will have to wait.
Address: 121 Mill St, Lynnville, TN 38472
2. Swiss Pantry Inc
Pecan in a fried pie? Swiss Pantry makes that happen, and apricot sits right beside it on the list of local favorites.
You’ll find this country store on David Crockett Parkway in Belvidere, in Franklin County near Winchester. Chattanooga and Nashville folks can both reach it on a manageable day trip.
Inside, the shelves lean hard into Amish-style baking. Breads, cakes, cookies, whole pies, and homemade fried pies share space with fresh donuts.
Those donuts are a signature item, and they deserve their own moment. Grabbing a box alongside your pies is simply good strategy.
The deli side adds sandwiches, so lunch is covered without another stop. Breakfast and coffee are on offer as well, which makes an early arrival pretty tempting.
Strawberry pies get attention here too. It’s a bakery where the whole pie case competes for your eyes.
Saturdays bring the biggest crowds, from morning through afternoon. If you like a calmer browse, a weekday visit tends to feel easier.
Free parking and free wi-fi make the stop simple. There’s a restroom too, which road-trippers always appreciate.
Hours run 9 AM to 6 PM on weekdays and 9 AM to 5 PM on Saturday. Sunday is closed, so plan your pecan pie mission accordingly.
Address: 10026 David Crockett Pkwy, Belvidere, TN 37306
3. The Apple Barn & Cider Mill
A barn built in 1910 still anchors this working apple orchard, and the fried pies inside carry that orchard spirit. Apples here aren’t a theme, they’re the whole point.
The Apple Barn & Cider Mill sits on Apple Valley Road in Sevierville, just off the busy parkway corridor. It makes a natural pause on the way into or out of the Smokies.
One detail sets these pies apart from the others on this list. The dough leans closer to a fluffy fried dough than a flaky pie crust.
That texture surprises first-timers in a fun way. Fresh and warm from the bakery, they’re a different kind of fried pie experience.
The bakery also turns out home-baked whole pies, donuts, and other hand pies. A cider bar and general store round things out, along with souvenirs for anyone shopping for gifts.
Apple slushies are another family favorite worth trying. Pair one with a fried apple pie and you’ve got a very on-theme snack.
Some families call this a stop they make every single trip. A few even say the pies nearly justify a four-hour drive on their own.
Weekend afternoons get busy, so evenings tend to run quieter. Hours are 8 AM to 7 PM Monday, 9 AM to 7 PM Tuesday through Saturday, and 9 AM to 5:30 PM Sunday.
Address: 230 Apple Valley Rd, Sevierville, TN 37862
4. The Country Cupboard
Sometimes the best item in a store isn’t even on the food menu board. At The Country Cupboard in Crossville, fried pies quietly steal the show anyway.
The market sits on West Avenue, a handy stop on the Cumberland Plateau. Knoxville and Nashville drivers can both swing through without a big detour off the interstate.
Walk the aisles and it feels like an Amish country store. You’ll spot cheese, deli ham, Amish butter, jams, local dairy, and fresh bread.
Fresh custard pie joins the lineup as well. Between that and the fried pies, dessert decisions get complicated fast.
Hungry for something hearty? The sandwich shop in the back handles that, with a fried bologna sandwich among the highlights.
Waffle fries come into play too. It’s a very satisfying way to justify a fried pie for the road.
Here’s a practical move: grab deli meats and cheese for later, then add pies for the drive. You leave with lunch, groceries, and dessert in one stop.
Free parking is available in the lot and on the street. Saturday afternoon is the busiest stretch, so earlier visits may feel calmer.
Hours run 9 AM to 4:30 PM on weekdays and 9 AM to 4 PM on Saturday. The store stays closed on Sunday.
Address: 1782 West Ave, Crossville, TN 38555
5. Dutch Maid Delights
Amish peanut butter tucked inside a fried pie sounds almost too good to be real. Dutch Maid Delights in Greeneville makes it, plus a lineup that keeps going.
Flavors stretch from blueberry cream cheese and strawberry cream cheese to black raspberry and peaches and cream. Classic peach, apple, cherry, and chocolate hold down the familiar side.
Crusts are known for being tender and flaky. It’s a pie shop that bakes fruit-based and cream-based pies daily, so freshness is the routine.
The shop sits on rural Warrensburg Road outside Greeneville in East Tennessee. Even vacationers headed to North Carolina cross the state line just to stock up.
That says a lot about Tennessee pride, honestly. When out-of-state travelers detour for your pies, you’re doing something right.
It’s also a small business that employs local people. Your snack run supports the community, which makes the second dozen feel downright responsible.
Know before you go: there’s no dine-in seating. Plan to take your pies to go, which pairs nicely with a scenic back-road drive.
Timing matters most here. The shop opens Monday through Friday from 8 AM to 3 PM, and it’s closed on weekends.
A weekday road trip suddenly sounds like a fine idea. Call it a personal day for pie.
Address: 3790 Warrensburg Rd, Greeneville, TN 37743
6. Muddy Pond General Store
A place called Muddy Pond probably isn’t where you’d expect some of the plateau’s most talked-about fried pies. That’s half the charm of this little general store.
Muddy Pond General Store sits on Muddy Pond Road outside Monterey, in a quiet farming community. Getting there means winding country roads, which feels like part of the adventure.
Shelves hold bulk food, baking supplies, and deli meats. A specialized leather shop adds a twist you won’t find at most bakeries.
Then there are the fruit fried hand pies. Fried apple pies have been known to come out still warm, which is the dream scenario.
Fresh bread is another reason to linger near the baked goods. Grab a loaf while you’re at it, because the drive home deserves company.
For many travelers, this stop is simply non-negotiable. Driving through Muddy Pond without pulling over feels a little like skipping dessert.
Some fans go big with their praise, calling these the best fried pies on the planet. Bold words, but you’re welcome to test the theory yourself.
Saturdays get the most traffic, from morning into the afternoon. Weekday mornings tend to be quieter for easy browsing.
Hours run 8:30 AM to 5 PM Monday through Saturday. Sunday is closed.
Address: 3608 Muddy Pond Rd, Monterey, TN 38574
7. Bäckermann’s Country Market
West Tennessee gets its turn in the fried pie spotlight thanks to Bäckermann’s Country Market. Memphis folks, this one’s within easy reach.
The family-owned grocery and cafe sits along US-64 in Whiteville. It’s a straightforward highway stop between Memphis and points east.
Fried pies rank among the regular favorites here. Shoppers often bundle them with honey, roll butter, apple butter, and sourdough bread.
Then comes the jam and jelly wall, which is famously huge. Some call it the largest selection they’ve seen in one place.
Raw unfiltered honey with comb is another standout. Pickled beets have their own fan club too, if you like a tangy side quest.
Bringing the dog along? The store even carries dog treats, so your co-pilot gets a souvenir.
The cafe side serves deli-style soups and sandwiches. That makes it easy to turn a pie run into a proper lunch break.
Free parking sits in the lot and along the street. Saturday afternoon is the busiest time, while weekday evenings run quieter.
Hours are 9 AM to 6 PM Monday through Friday and 8 AM to 5 PM on Saturday. Sunday is closed.
It’s proof that great fried pies aren’t just an East Tennessee thing. The whole state gets to brag.
Address: 260 US-64, Whiteville, TN 38075
8. Apple Valley Mountain Village & Cafe
For some families, the Smokies trip doesn’t officially start until a fried apple hand pie is in hand. Apple Valley Mountain Village & Cafe in Townsend is where that tradition happens.
The barnlike building sits on East Lamar Alexander Parkway, the main road leading toward Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Picking up a pie on the way in feels practically required.
Fried Pie is a highlighted menu item at the cafe. Pecan brownies and other sweets make the dessert counter hard to rush.
Not just a pie stop, though. The cafe serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with BBQ pulled pork sandwiches, brisket sandwiches, and a Black Bear BLT.
Next door, the general store and gift shop are packed with fun finds. Quilts, flags, honey, coffee, jams, spices, cheeses, and soaps fill the shelves.
Families will appreciate the kids’ menu and high chairs. Dogs are welcome inside and out, so nobody waits in the car.
It’s the only stop on this list open seven days a week. Hours run 8 AM to 7 PM daily.
Weekend mornings and afternoons draw the biggest crowds. Thursday mornings tend to be calmer if you can swing it.
Parking is usually plentiful, which helps on busy mountain weekends. Grab an extra pie for the ride home, because one never quite covers it.
Address: 7138 E Lamar Alexander Pkwy, Townsend, TN 37882
Share this story
