Some places surprise you the second you walk through the door, and this one in South Carolina does exactly that. What looks like just another coastal spot turns out to feel more like a museum full of ships, sharks, and endless plates of fresh seafood.
I came in curious and hungry, expecting a simple meal, but left absolutely stuffed and grinning. If you love crab legs and a little bit of wonder with your dinner, keep reading.
Where the Nautical Feast Begins
Tucked along North Kings Highway in Myrtle Beach, this sprawling seafood destination sits at 9593 N Kings Hwy, easy to spot and even easier to fall in love with. It bills itself as a vast, nautical-themed seafood buffet, and that description barely scratches the surface.
Diners wander from station to station beneath mounted sharks, filling plates with all-you-can-eat treasures from the sea. Regulars mention that the parking lot fills up fast, sometimes before the doors even open.
What sets it apart is the sheer scale. Visitors say it feels less like a restaurant and more like an experience, complete with multiple dining rooms and countless food stations.
If you are new to the area and craving Calabash-style seafood, this is the kind of spot locals happily point you toward.
A Restaurant That Doubles as a Museum
Walking inside feels like stepping onto a grand old ship, and that is no accident. Guests describe the space as part restaurant, part museum, with model ships, maritime memorabilia, and displays about naval history scattered throughout.
While you eat, you can wander over and learn about vessels, uniforms, and seafaring life. Several visitors mention that this detail turns an ordinary meal into something genuinely memorable.
One guest compared the entrance to walking into the Titanic, at least the version imagined in the movies. The staff, dressed in full uniform, add to that sense of stepping back in time.
For families with curious kids or history buffs who love a good story, the decor gives you plenty to talk about between trips to the buffet. It is entertainment and dinner rolled into one big adventure.
The Crab Legs Everyone Talks About
Crab legs are the undeniable star here, mentioned nearly a thousand times by delighted diners. Snow crab legs are kept stocked, steaming, and easy to crack, which is exactly what you want at an all-you-can-eat spread.
One guest raved that the legs were always fresh and full of flavor, calling them a highlight of the whole visit. Another noted that batches can vary slightly, with one round tougher than the next, so a little patience pays off.
The phrase all you can eat comes up again and again, and crab lovers treat it like a personal challenge. Regulars suggest coming hungry and pacing yourself so you can go back for seconds, or thirds.
If cracking shells and pulling out sweet, tender meat sounds like your kind of evening, this buffet was practically built for you.
Calabash-Style Fried Shrimp and Oysters
Light, crispy, and never greasy is how one enthusiastic diner described the Calabash-style fried shrimp and oysters, and that reputation runs deep here. Calabash cooking is a coastal Carolina tradition, and this kitchen leans into it fully.
Fried oysters earn special praise, showing up as a favorite for many first-time visitors. The bang shrimp, in particular, won over one guest who called it their top pick aside from the crab legs.
Not every plate is perfect, and a few diners felt some fried items leaned too oily on their visit. Still, when the fryers are humming along, the results are golden and satisfying.
For anyone who grew up loving a proper Southern seafood fry, these stations deliver that familiar crunch you keep coming back for, plate after plate.
Carving Stations and Prime Rib for Non-Seafood Fans
Not everyone at your table will be a seafood devotee, and this buffet plans for that beautifully. Carving and made-to-order stations feature tender meats like prime rib, which earned an outstanding review from more than one hungry guest.
Prime rib alone gets nearly a hundred mentions, and the steak tenderloin drew praise for being almost melt-in-your-mouth good. One diner did note the beef occasionally runs a touch salty, so tastes may vary.
Honesty matters, and a few folks felt the roast beef missed the mark on flavor. Since this is first and foremost a seafood spot, that is easy to forgive.
Bringing along a landlubber or a picky eater? The carving stations mean nobody leaves hungry, and everyone finds something worth going back for a second helping.
Southern Sides and Hush Puppies
Golden hush puppies are a beloved fixture here, racking up nearly two hundred mentions from happy eaters. Crispy on the outside and soft in the middle, they are the kind of side you keep sneaking onto your plate.
Beyond the puppies, you will find classic Southern comfort food done right. One guest praised the real mashed potatoes as tasty and well prepared, a small detail that fans clearly appreciate.
Other favorites include salmon patties, crab cakes, and a vegetable beef soup that a diner called delicious. The mac and cheese gets mixed reactions, loved by some and considered too heavy by others.
Rounding out plates with these homestyle staples makes the meal feel warm and familiar. For picky kids, sides like mac and cheese and fries offer a reliable, friendly landing spot.
A Dessert Bar Like Its Own Restaurant
Save room, because the dessert spread might just steal the show. One guest described it as feeling like its own restaurant, loaded with cakes, pies, soft serve, and much more.
Soft serve ice cream is a crowd pleaser, popping up as a hit with kids and adults alike. Cobblers get special love too, especially when topped with a scoop of that creamy soft serve.
A few visitors mention Ranger cookies and brownies as standouts, while another raved that the cookies were beyond amazing. Not every review agrees, though, as some found certain desserts less impressive.
With dozens of options portioned into neat little cups and squares, sampling becomes half the fun. Grab a few, mix and match, and treat yourself.
After all that seafood, a sweet finish feels earned.
The Grand Welcome and Guided Tour
First impressions here are hard to beat. Waiters and hostesses stand near the door in professional uniforms, and one guest said it made the entrance feel wonderfully fancy, almost cinematic.
Rather than pointing you toward a plate and vanishing, the staff walk you to your seat and give a mini tour of the buffet. Visitors describe this as a thoughtful touch that sets the whole meal in motion.
The tour explains where everything lives, which helps a lot in such an enormous space. One diner admitted it can get loud inside, making it tricky to catch every word.
Still, being greeted so warmly by uniformed staff turns arrival into part of the fun. It is a small ceremony that makes you feel less like a customer and more like a welcomed guest.
Service That Keeps the Table Happy
Great servers can make or break a buffet, and this one earns steady applause. Guests repeatedly mention attentive staff who clear tables quickly and refill drinks without being asked.
One family celebrating two birthdays said their server made the whole evening feel special. Another large party of nearly thirty people praised their server for keeping everyone taken care of smoothly.
Kindness shows up in the little things too. A parent shared that the team went out of their way to help their autistic child feel comfortable, even finding quieter seating and accommodating food preferences.
You never feel rushed, according to several diners, but you are never ignored either. For a place this busy, that balance is impressive.
The friendly, uniformed crew clearly plays a huge role in why families keep returning year after year.
Who This Feast Is Perfect For
Big groups thrive in this lively, spacious dining hall. Parties of eight, twenty-nine, and everything in between have celebrated here, and the roomy layout handles crowds with ease.
Families love it because there truly is something for everyone. Even the pickiest eaters find fries, mac and cheese, and ice cream, while adults chase crab legs and prime rib.
One couple celebrated a birthday and left, in their playful words, feeling like two watermelons. Others describe it as a fun, relaxed spot equally suited for date night or a big reunion.
The atmosphere is lively without being overwhelming, striking a nice middle ground. Whether you are on a family vacation, a team trip, or simply a serious food mission, this buffet welcomes the whole crew with open arms.
Hours, Prices, and Planning Your Visit
Timing matters here more than you might expect. The restaurant opens daily at 3:30 PM and closes at 9 PM, so this is a dinner-focused destination all week long.
Come early, because guests warn that lines form even before the doors open, especially on weekends. Several diners arrived right around 3:25 PM and found a sizable crowd already waiting, though seating moved quickly.
Pricing sits on the higher side, with reported buffet costs ranging from about $49.99 to $53 per person, plus drinks around $4. A gratuity may be added automatically, and one guest noted the total climbs with tax and tip.
Many feel the price is fair if you fill up on crab legs and higher-value seafood. You can reach them at +1 843-449-0821 or check originalbenjamins.com to plan ahead.
The Final Word on This Seafood Adventure
Coming here is about more than dinner, and that is what keeps people coming back. Guests describe it as an experience, blending museum-like decor, over a hundred and seventy items, and genuinely warm service into one unforgettable outing.
Is it perfect? Not quite.
Some visitors found a few fried items greasy, certain desserts underwhelming, and the price a bit steep for smaller appetites.
Yet the overwhelming feeling is one of delight. Many call it the best seafood buffet they have tried, urging newcomers to come hungry and never skip the crab legs or hush puppies.
If you find yourself near Myrtle Beach with a big appetite and a sense of curiosity, this nautical wonderland is worth the visit. Pace yourself, explore every station, and leave room for that dessert bar.
Share this story
