There is a small Italian restaurant sitting on a historic street in central Kansas that has quietly racked up nearly 3,000 Google reviews and a 4.6-star rating, and most people driving through on I-70 have no idea it exists. That feels like a genuine injustice.
The kind of place that earns that many reviews in a mid-sized Kansas city is not just serving pasta; it is serving memories, reunions, and road-trip highlights that people feel compelled to write home about. I made a point of stopping in during a recent cross-country drive, and what I found was a warm, lively dining room packed with locals and travelers alike, all happily working through plates of food that were frankly embarrassingly large.
From a legendary chopped salad to a meatball the size of a softball, this place has a personality all its own. Keep reading, because the story behind this restaurant is just as satisfying as the food on the plate.
Where You Will Actually Find This Place
Right in the heart of downtown Salina, Kansas, at 158 S Santa Fe Avenue, sits one of the most surprisingly impressive Italian restaurants I have ever stumbled across on a road trip. The address alone sets the tone: Santa Fe Avenue is lined with historic brick buildings, outdoor murals, and a genuinely charming small-city energy that punches well above its weight.
Martinelli’s Little Italy has been anchored to this spot since 2001, and it shows in the best possible way. The restaurant feels rooted, confident, and completely at home on a street that rewards slow walking and curious eyes.
You are not hunting for a hidden alley or a tucked-away sign; the place presents itself with quiet pride on one of Salina’s most storied blocks.
The Stiefel Theatre sits just across the street, making this an ideal dinner destination before or after a show. Hours run Monday through Saturday, 11 AM to 10 PM, with Sunday as the one day of rest.
Reservations are strongly recommended for weekend evenings.
The Man Who Brought Italian Cooking to the Kansas Plains
Tony Dong grew up in Concordia, Kansas, which is not exactly the first place you would associate with authentic Italian cooking. But a stretch of time working in an Italian restaurant in Chicago changed everything for him.
He absorbed family recipes, learned the rhythms of a serious Italian kitchen, and came home to Kansas with a vision.
In 2001, he opened Martinelli’s Little Italy in Salina, bringing those Chicago-honed recipes to a community that was ready for something beyond the expected. The restaurant is family-owned and has remained so, which gives it a consistency and soul that chain restaurants simply cannot manufacture.
What Tony built is not a theme restaurant or a novelty act. It is a genuine expression of Italian-American culinary tradition, planted firmly in the Kansas heartland and tended with obvious care.
The fact that nearly 3,000 people have taken the time to leave a review tells you everything about how deeply the community has embraced what he started more than two decades ago.
A Room That Feels Like It Has Always Been There
The moment you walk through the door, the atmosphere does the talking. A copper bar anchors one side of the room, gleaming warmly under the light.
Snug booths sit on risers near clean front windows, giving diners a slightly elevated view of the street outside while keeping the sense of privacy intact. Cozy alcoves tuck away smaller tables for quieter conversations.
The overall effect is genuinely old-school Italian-American, the kind of setting where red-checked tablecloths feel exactly right and not at all kitschy. Fresh bread arrives at the table while you are still settling in, and the smell of garlic and simmering tomato sauce drifts through the room like a standing invitation to order more than you planned.
There is also a large private event space that accommodates up to 200 guests, which explains why the restaurant regularly hosts community dinners, volunteer events, and celebrations of all kinds. The room adapts to the occasion, but the warmth stays constant no matter how many people are filling the seats.
The Chopped Salad That Steals the Show Every Single Time
Nobody expects the salad to be the most talked-about item at an Italian restaurant, but here we are. The Martinelli’s Chopped Salad has earned its own loyal following, and after one bite, the enthusiasm makes complete sense.
Crisp iceberg lettuce gets tossed with diced chicken, ripe tomato, tangy Danish blue cheese, creamy avocado, smoky bacon, and fresh green onion.
The dressing is the real secret weapon: a house blend of basil, oregano, fresh parsley, lemon juice, a touch of sweetness, and a mayonnaise base that ties every element together in a way that feels both bright and satisfying. Even the quarter-size portion is substantial enough to share between two people as a starter.
It shows up in reviews constantly, recommended by servers as a must-order and praised by first-timers who came in expecting to focus on pasta. The salad alone is worth planning a stop around, which is not something I say lightly about a side dish.
Order it first, and thank yourself later.
Pasta Dishes That Earn Their Generous Reputation
The pasta menu at Martinelli’s reads like a greatest-hits collection of Italian-American comfort food, and the kitchen delivers on every entry. The lasagna is a signature dish for good reason: it arrives thick, layered, and deeply satisfying, the kind of portion that makes you reconsider your life choices about ordering a full size on your first visit.
Spaghetti with marinara comes with a meatball that reviewers have compared to the size of a baseball, packed with flavor and cooked with care. The marinara itself leans Sicilian, with a spice level that surprises first-timers in the best possible way.
Fettuccine Alfredo, available with broccoli and optional chicken, is rich and creamy without feeling heavy.
Beyond those classics, the menu includes beef ravioli, four-cheese manicotti stuffed to capacity, chicken carbonara, and a penne special with Alfredo, cherry tomatoes, and spinach. The portion system of quarter, half, and family sizes means you can tailor your order intelligently.
First-timers are almost universally advised by staff to start with the quarter size.
When Kansas Beef Meets Italian Technique
Kansas is beef country, and Martinelli’s has the good sense to honor that fact while keeping one foot firmly in Italian culinary tradition. The steaks here are sourced from the state’s leading beef producers, and the kitchen treats them with the kind of respect that prime Kansas cattle deserve.
The ribeye is a particular standout, available with a mushroom Marsala sauce that adds richness and depth without overwhelming the natural flavor of the beef. One diner who requested a Pittsburgh-style sear on their birthday ribeye found that the kitchen not only agreed to the request but delivered what they described as the best ribeye of their nearly six decades of eating steak.
That is a bold claim, and it was made without hesitation.
The ability to blend Italian technique with locally sourced ingredients is one of the quieter achievements of this restaurant. It is not something that shows up on every menu item, but when it does, the result is a dish that feels native to Kansas and deeply Italian at the same time.
That balance is harder to pull off than it looks.
Pizza, Piccata, and the Art of Keeping Everyone Happy
Not every table at Martinelli’s is ordering pasta, and the kitchen clearly enjoys the variety. The thin-crust pizza, cut into squares rather than the typical wedge, is a small but telling detail that signals a kitchen with its own point of view.
Coby’s Pizza features an Alfredo sauce base topped with artichoke hearts, spinach, and garlic, which is a combination that rewards the adventurous orderer.
Chicken piccata is another item that comes up repeatedly in conversations about the menu, praised for its balance of bright lemon, savory capers, and tender chicken. The sweet-and-salty dynamic in that dish has converted more than a few people who arrived planning to order pasta exclusively.
Then there is the calamari, served as strips rather than rings, plated on lettuce that absorbs any excess oil from frying. It is a small technique that makes a noticeable difference in texture and presentation.
The toasted beef ravioli appetizer, served with a generous pool of marinara for dipping, is another crowd favorite worth ordering before the main event arrives.
Desserts That Justify Saving Room
Tiramisu at Martinelli’s is not a token dessert tacked onto the end of the menu. It is a serious, generously portioned finale that people specifically mention when they talk about their meals here.
The layers of cream and coffee-soaked cake are balanced and rich without becoming cloying, and the portion size is large enough that sharing is not just recommended, it is practically necessary.
Cannoli are another fixture, delivering the classic combination of crispy shell and sweet ricotta filling that Italian dessert tradition demands. Crème brûlée rounds out the sweet options for those who prefer something a little more refined and less overtly Italian in its roots.
One reviewer who attended a museum volunteer dinner in the private event space specifically highlighted the cannoli as a standout of the buffet, which says something about how well the kitchen executes even when cooking at scale. The desserts here are not an afterthought.
They are a proper closing argument for why this restaurant has earned nearly 3,000 reviews and the loyalty of a genuinely devoted regular crowd.
Service That Turns First-Timers Into Regulars
The service at Martinelli’s is one of the most consistently praised elements across nearly 3,000 reviews, and the praise is specific rather than generic. Servers are credited with guiding first-time visitors through the portion-size system, steering them away from the common mistake of ordering a half-size on their debut visit and ending up with enough food for a small family reunion.
That kind of attentiveness is not accidental. It reflects a culture of hospitality that runs through the entire operation, from the person answering the phone for takeout orders to the staff managing a packed Friday night dining room.
When an undercooked dish reached a table, the manager responded quickly with an apology and an offer to replace it, which is exactly the right response and exactly what keeps people coming back.
Travelers who stopped in on a whim, recommended by strangers at a hotel, have left describing it as the best Italian food they have ever eaten. That kind of word-of-mouth credibility is earned one table at a time, and the staff here clearly understands that every interaction is an opportunity to add another loyal visitor to the list.
How the Restaurant Survived Construction and a Pandemic
Two decades of operation in a mid-sized Kansas city is an achievement on its own. Doing it while navigating a multi-year downtown streetscape construction project that tore up the roads, sidewalks, and parking immediately in front of the building is a different level of determination entirely.
The construction project was a massive public and private partnership that reshaped downtown Salina, and for businesses like Martinelli’s, it meant months of reduced foot traffic, blocked entrances, and the kind of logistical headaches that have shuttered more fragile operations. Tony Dong kept the restaurant going through all of it.
Then came the pandemic, which forced another round of adaptation. The dining room closed temporarily, and the team shifted to takeout and delivery, adding take-and-bake pizza options to keep the menu relevant and accessible.
The fact that the restaurant emerged from both challenges with its reputation not just intact but stronger is a testament to the quality of the food and the loyalty it had already earned. Resilience, it turns out, is also on the menu here.
Why a Stop Here Is Worth the Detour
Martinelli’s Little Italy is the kind of place that reframes your expectations of what a road trip meal can be. Most stops along I-70 through Kansas offer predictability.
This one offers something genuinely memorable: a family-owned Italian restaurant with nearly 3,000 reviews, a 4.6-star rating, and a menu that holds up to any big-city comparison.
Travelers from Indiana, Colorado, North Carolina, and Florida have all made it a point to stop again on return trips, which is about as clear a signal of quality as you can get. The combination of generous portions, thoughtful service, a flexible menu, and an atmosphere that feels both casual and special is not easy to replicate.
A reservation for weekend evenings is strongly recommended, and the quarter-size portions are the smart starting point for anyone dining for the first time. The full address is 158 S Santa Fe Avenue, Salina, KS 67401, and the phone number is 785-826-9190 for reservations or takeout orders.
Some restaurants earn their reputation over time. This one has clearly been earning it, one hearty plate at a time.
Share this story
