Some of the best meals hide behind plain glass doors, wedged between ordinary shops in a parking lot you would normally drive right past. That is exactly where I found a little Puerto Rican kitchen in North Carolina that smelled like garlic, plantains, and slow-roasted pork the second I stepped inside.
Reggaeton was playing, a domino table sat in the corner, and suddenly the island felt a lot closer than a plane ride away. If you love food with a story and prices that will not empty your wallet, keep reading.
A Caribbean Kitchen Tucked Into Matthews
Picture a regular shopping center on Margaret Wallace Road, the kind with parking spaces and plain storefronts. Inside suite 109, though, sits El Cilantro, a Puerto Rican restaurant that has quietly become a favorite for folks across the Matthews, Mint Hill, and Charlotte area.
From the outside, nothing shouts island getaway. That is part of the fun.
Visitors often describe it as a hidden gem, the sort of spot you only learn about when a friend leans over and whispers, you have to try this place.
The menu covers classic home-style Puerto Rican cooking. Think mofongo, pernil, crispy fritters, stuffed potato balls, and coconut desserts.
Some guests have driven two hours or more just to eat here, including a group that came all the way from Western North Carolina. For a strip mall stop, that is a pretty impressive pull, and it says a lot about what comes out of the kitchen.
Five Years of Island Flavor
Birthdays matter, even for restaurants. El Cilantro recently celebrated its fifth anniversary, and guests who attended say the party had great food, live music, and an atmosphere that kept everyone smiling.
Five years is a real milestone for a small, family-feel eatery. Plenty of little restaurants come and go, especially in busy suburban plazas.
Staying open and building a following takes steady cooking and a crowd that keeps coming back.
Long before that celebration, early visitors were already calling it a rare find. One diner noted that the Charlotte area had a short supply of great Hispanic food and was thrilled to stumble onto this spot.
Others mention that the meals remind them of childhood dishes from the South Bronx or of family tables back on the island.
That sense of memory is the secret ingredient here. People do not just eat.
They reconnect with something familiar, one plate at a time.
Pernil and the Pork That Started the Buzz
Crispy, garlicky, and slow-cooked, pernil is the dish that makes Puerto Rican families gather around the holiday table. At El Cilantro, it is a menu staple worth ordering.
One Saturday-night diner called the pernil very flavorful and especially recommended it for anyone craving pork that is not too greasy. Pair it with arroz con gandules, the island’s famous rice with pigeon peas, and you have a classic plate.
Fair warning, though. Pork can be hit or miss depending on the cut and the day.
A few guests found the pork chunks or chops on the drier side, so it may help to ask your server what is cooking best that afternoon.
Fun fact: in Puerto Rico, roast pork is so beloved that whole roadside towns are famous for it. Getting a taste of that tradition in a North Carolina plaza feels like a small, savory miracle.
Bacalaitos, Alcapurrias, and Other Fried Treasures
Ask regulars what to order first, and one word keeps popping up: bacalaitos. These thin, crunchy codfish fritters are the most talked-about item on the menu, and fans call them crispy, plentiful, and cooked just right.
Close behind is the relleno de papa, a golden potato ball stuffed with seasoned beef. A diner who grew up in the South Bronx said it tasted exactly like the ones from childhood, which is about the highest praise a fritter can earn.
Other crowd-pleasers include alcapurrias, sorullos made from cornmeal, and shrimp empanadas. A spread of different sauces sits ready for dipping, so you can experiment with every bite.
Texture preferences vary, of course. Some people like their bacalaitos extra crunchy, while others prefer them softer.
If you lean toward a lighter fry, mention it when ordering. Sharing a few appetizers around the table is the easiest way to sample the island.
Mofongo in Many Delicious Forms
Mashed green plantains, garlic, and a little magic. That is mofongo, and El Cilantro serves it in more ways than you might expect.
Guests have ordered mofongo with shrimp, with churrasco steak, and even with octopus. One Puerto Rican diner could not stop raving about the mofongo churrasco, while another visitor praised a shrimp version as perfectly prepared and beautifully seasoned.
The kitchen also gets creative. A past guest described a sancocho stew served with mofongo tucked inside, calling it a delightful new twist on a classic.
There is trifongo too, which mixes three types of plantain or root for a bigger, heartier mash.
Not every plate lands the same for everyone, and a few diners wanted more flavor in theirs. Still, for anyone new to Puerto Rican food, mofongo is the dish to start with.
It is filling, comforting, and about as island as a meal can get in the Piedmont.
Steak, Seafood, and Sandwich Favorites
Not in a pork mood? No problem.
The menu stretches well beyond pernil, and one guest summed it up nicely by saying there is something for everyone.
Bistec encebollado, tender steak smothered in onions, is a go-to for several regulars. They pair it with white rice, beans, and either tostones or sweet maduros.
Churrasco is another steak choice, though one fan joked that you need to catch the kitchen on a lucky day for an extra-large portion.
Seafood lovers have options too. Diners mention shrimp stew that tastes rich and comforting, plus two different kinds of snapper to choose from.
Then there is the tripleta, a towering Puerto Rican sandwich loaded with three meats. A Cuban sandwich with tostones also gets a nod.
Sides range from fries and salad to fresh avocado, so you can build a plate that feels generous and homemade without much effort.
Tembleque and Tropical Sips
Save room. Seriously.
The tembleque here has its own little fan club, and one visitor admitted to already dreaming about the next spoonful.
Tembleque is a silky coconut pudding, often dusted with cinnamon. Its name comes from the Spanish word for trembling, because it wiggles when you set it down.
Guests praise El Cilantro’s version for its real coconut flavor.
The drink list is a treat in itself. Tropical juices and milkshakes come in flavors like soursop, papaya, and parcha, which is passion fruit.
One diner even called the natural juices the best in town.
Island sodas show up too, including Kola Champagne, a sweet, bubbly cream soda style drink, and Malta India, a malty soft drink brought in from Puerto Rico. For kids and grown-ups alike, a fruity shake and a wobbly coconut dessert make a cheerful ending to the meal.
Dominoes, Reggaeton, and a Slice of Old San Juan
Walk in and listen. Reggaeton is usually playing, and the room hums with families chatting over plates of rice and plantains.
Guests love the little details. A playable domino table waits in the corner, a nod to the game you will spot on porches all over Puerto Rico.
A colorful art piece of Old San Juan brightens the wall, and the decor feels warm and homey rather than fancy.
Several diners say the atmosphere carried them somewhere else entirely. One felt transported to the Bronx, another called it a little slice of PR, and a Spanish-speaking visitor said it was perfect for eating mofongo with family and catching up on the latest gossip.
That relaxed vibe suits nearly anyone. Families, curious first-timers, and homesick islanders all seem to find a comfortable seat here, especially on a cozy winter afternoon when a hot plate feels extra welcome.
Hours, Prices, and Smart Timing
Plan ahead, because El Cilantro is closed on Mondays. Tuesday, Thursday, Friday, and Saturday it runs from 11 AM to 8 PM.
Wednesday and Sunday hours are shorter, 11 AM to 5 PM.
Budget travelers will be happy. Visitors describe the prices as very reasonable and the portions as generous, saying you truly get your money’s worth.
That makes it a solid pick for an affordable day trip around the Charlotte area.
Timing can shape your visit. Some guests got their food in under 20 minutes, while one Sunday afternoon crowd at about 3 PM led to long waits and mixed-up orders.
A weekday lunch may feel calmer.
Many servers earn warm praise, and one was singled out for being attentive without hovering. A heads-up for vegetarians, though: one guest noted there were no vegetarian options.
Call 704-910-2027 if you have questions before heading over.
Worth the Drive for a Taste of the Island
So, should you go? For anyone who loves food with heart, the answer leans toward yes.
El Cilantro is not polished or flashy. It is a family-style kitchen in a shopping plaza, and like any small spot, it has its off days.
A few diners left disappointed by dry meat or slow service. Many more walked out full, happy, and already planning a return trip.
What stands out is the feeling. Bacalaitos crackle, reggaeton plays, dominoes click in the corner, and a coconut tembleque waits at the end.
For homesick Puerto Ricans and curious North Carolinians alike, that combination can be hard to find.
Bring a friend, order a few appetizers to share, and try the pernil. Whether you are passing through Matthews or making a special trip from the mountains or the coast, this unassuming kitchen may just become your new favorite island escape.
Share this story
