Some of the best food memories in Illinois start with a simple smell drifting out of a plain little shop. You follow your nose, expecting a quick snack, and walk out holding a warm bag you cannot stop reaching into.
This is one of those places, where a line of cars can stretch around the lot and nobody seems to mind the wait. If sweet and cheesy popcorn sounds like a strange match, keep reading, because this spot might change your mind.
A South Side Popcorn Stop on 87th Street
Tucked along East 87th Street near Cottage Grove, this Garrett Popcorn Shop sits far from the downtown crowds most tourists picture. It is a neighborhood stop on Chicago’s South Side, and that is exactly its charm.
The address is 737 E 87th St, and visitors say it is easy to find. There is plenty of parking, which already makes it feel different from the busy shops near Michigan Avenue.
Better still, there is a drive-thru, a rare perk for a popcorn shop.
Inside, the focus is simple. The store sells sweet and savory gourmet popcorn in bags, tins, and party packs, plus seasonal flavors that rotate through the year.
Nobody comes here for fancy decor. People come for popcorn, and many of them come back again and again, sometimes bringing the whole family along for the ride and the snack.
From Madison Street Roots to a Citywide Habit
Back in 1949, the Garrett story began on Madison Street, and the recipe for a Chicago snack habit was born. Decades later, the name still pops up in nearly every conversation about the city’s must-try treats.
Longtime fans remember a time when Garrett shops seemed to sit on just about every downtown corner. One visitor recalled a parent grabbing a bag on the way home, a small ritual that stuck.
Another said the popcorn has been number one since childhood, and now the kids and grandkids eat it too.
That kind of loyalty is hard to fake. It grows slowly, one warm bag at a time, passed from one generation to the next.
The 87th Street shop carries that tradition into a neighborhood setting, where the history feels less like a museum piece and more like a family habit that simply never stopped.
The Famous Sweet and Cheesy Chicago Mix
Caramel and cheddar in one bag sounds like a mistake until the first handful. Then it makes total sense.
The Chicago Mix blends crunchy caramel corn with bright orange cheese corn, and it is the order regulars talk about most.
Fans call it the best thing on the menu and a staple of the city. One visitor said not to leave Chicago without a bag.
Another described it simply as a great combination, salty and sweet trading places with every bite.
Some shoppers fine-tune the ratio, asking for more cheese or more caramel to suit their taste. You may also hear it called the Garrett Mix or the Garrett Special, depending on who you ask.
Whatever the name, the idea stays the same. Two flavors that should not work together end up being the reason people drive across town for a refill.
Cheese Corn, Caramel Crisp, and Nutty Extras
Not everyone wants the mix, and that is fine. The menu has plenty of other paths worth exploring.
Cheese popcorn on its own gets loads of attention from visitors. Some love its bold, salty punch, while others find it a bit much and prefer it balanced with caramel.
The caramel crisp earns steady praise, with one guest calling the crunch perfectly balanced.
Nut lovers have options too. The cashew mix and pecan popcorn come up often among regulars, and an almond caramel crisp has fans of its own.
One longtime customer counted about six or seven varieties, noting the kernels are cooked all the way through instead of hard and half-popped.
There is even a vegan popcorn option, which one visitor was happy to point out. Seasonal flavors rotate in as well, so a repeat trip can turn up something new on the shelf.
Drive-Thru Lines and Patient Waits
Picture a line of cars snaking through the lot, every driver waiting for one thing. That scene is common here, and the drive-thru is the most talked-about feature of this location.
It is a huge convenience for families, busy commuters, and anyone grabbing a treat on the way home from work. Still, popularity has a cost.
Long lines come up often, and one visitor reported waiting a long stretch on a busy Saturday evening near closing time.
The tip from experience is simple. Go earlier in the day if you can, and allow some extra time on weekends.
Checking your bag before pulling away may also help, since a few guests mentioned order mix-ups. For many locals, though, the wait is part of the ritual.
Sitting in that line, smelling caramel through the window, builds just enough anticipation to make the first handful taste even better.
Friendly Faces Behind the Counter
A warm hello can turn a quick snack run into a memory. Plenty of visitors say the staff here does exactly that.
One guest returning to Chicago said a cheerful, patient employee made the trip feel like a welcome home. Another was impressed that workers wore hairnets, packed orders neatly, and kept good attitudes while staying busy.
A customer placing a huge order of 125 bags praised the manager and team for being quick and helpful.
Small kindnesses come up too. One shopper said an employee suggested buying a tin to keep popcorn fresher for travel and pointed out the best deal.
Others thanked staff for staying patient during big, complicated orders.
To be fair, not every visit goes smoothly. A few guests described rushed or mixed-up service.
Overall, though, the people behind the counter are a big reason many fans keep coming back.
The Freshness Factor and Smart Snacking Tips
Here is a little secret from seasoned fans: eat it warm. Garrett popcorn is made without preservatives, so it really shines right after it leaves the kettle.
One visitor watched batches being freshly made while waiting in line and called the result delicious. Another stored a small tin for about eight days and found the caramel still tasted fresh, while the cheese corn did not hold up as well.
Freshness is also the most common complaint. Some guests at this location found the cheese popcorn chewy or stale, which can happen with any snack made without additives.
The company says you can bring your order and receipt back within 24 hours for a replacement if something seems off.
For the best bite, enjoy cheese corn first. Save the caramel for later, and choose a sealed tin if you plan to travel.
Who Lines Up Here and Why
Grandparents, road-trippers, office workers, and party planners all end up in the same line. That mix of people says a lot about this shop.
Homesick Chicagoans treat it as a must-stop when they return, almost like checking in with an old friend. Out-of-state visitors, including one shopper from Ohio, stock up on bags for family and friends back home.
Locals swing by after work for an easy treat, and one pair described it as a solid snack to end the day.
It is not a fancy dessert shop, and it does not try to be. That plainness suits families with kids, folks planning events with big orders, and anyone who just wants a reliable Chicago flavor without a downtown parking battle.
If you love sweet and salty snacks, or you are hunting for a gift that screams Chicago, this neighborhood spot fits right in.
Hours, Tins, and a Final Word Before You Go
Planning ahead pays off. The shop opens at 10 am every day and closes at 8 pm Monday through Saturday, with a 7 pm close on Sunday.
Popcorn comes in bags, tins, and party packs. Several visitors called the pricing on the premium side, so set your budget before stocking up.
The souvenir tin is a fun extra and helps keep things fresher on long drives. For questions or concerns, the customer line is 888-476-7267, and the website is garrettpopcorn.com.
So, is it worth the trip? For many Chicagoans, the answer is a happy yes.
The Chicago Mix still tastes like tradition, the drive-thru is handy, and the staff often goes the extra mile. Go early, eat the cheese corn warm, and grab an extra bag for the ride home.
You will probably finish it before reaching the expressway anyway.
Share this story
