Somewhere off the beaten path in rural Oklahoma, tucked along a county road most people would never think to turn down, sits a small grocery store that has quietly become a legend among those lucky enough to stumble upon it. Word travels slowly out here, but it travels with conviction – people drive out of their way just to stock up, and they almost always leave with more than they planned to buy.
The prices alone are enough to make you do a double-take, but the homemade baked goods and the warmth of the people inside are what really seal the deal. If you love a good find, this place is going to feel like winning the lottery in the middle of a cornfield.
Where Troyer’s Discount Grocery Sits on the Map
County Road 1730 outside Coalgate, Oklahoma is not exactly a thoroughfare that shows up on most travel itineraries. Coalgate itself is a small Coal County seat with a population that fits comfortably in the “blink and you’ll miss it” category, and the road leading to Troyer’s Discount Grocery winds through the kind of open Oklahoma countryside that makes you feel pleasantly far from everything.
The address – 37097 CR 1730 – puts you solidly in the rural southeastern part of the state, not far from the Clarita area, which has its own small Amish community presence. Visitors coming from the state highway will need to watch for the turn, because the store’s modest profile does not exactly announce itself with fanfare.
One longtime visitor noted that a sign on the state highway before the Tupelo turn would help more travelers find the place. For now, knowing the address and having your GPS ready is your best bet.
The surrounding landscape, rolling and quiet, makes the drive feel like part of the experience rather than just the commute to get there.
The Amish Roots Behind the Store
Troyer’s has a history that connects it to the small Amish community around the Clarita area of Coal County. For years, the store operated with a distinctly Amish character – handmade goods, community baking, and a shopping experience that felt genuinely different from anything you’d find at a chain supermarket.
Longtime visitors have noted that the store’s identity has shifted somewhat over time, moving more toward a discount grocery format rather than a purely Amish-run operation. One reviewer pointed out that the true Amish stores in Clarita are largely gone now, though the Clarita Greenhouse still maintains a small store inside and remains a worthwhile stop for plant lovers.
Even so, Troyer’s has held onto a meaningful connection to that heritage. Amish-made breads, cheeses, and baked goods still appear on the shelves, and the community spirit that originally defined the store has not entirely disappeared.
The name Troyer itself is common among Amish families, and the store’s character still carries a handcrafted, community-rooted feeling that most discount groceries simply cannot replicate. That combination of old-world roots and practical pricing is a big part of what keeps people coming back.
The Egg Deal That Sounds Too Good to Be True
Around five dollars for 18 fresh eggs. Read that again.
At a time when a standard dozen at most supermarkets can run four dollars or more, stumbling onto an 18-count carton for roughly the same price feels less like a grocery run and more like a glitch in the system.
Visitors have specifically called out this egg deal as one of the standout reasons to make the trip. The eggs are described as fresh and real – not the heavily processed, warehouse-stored variety you might find at a big-box retailer.
For families, homesteaders, or anyone who simply cooks a lot, this kind of pricing on a staple item is genuinely significant.
It is the sort of deal that makes you want to call your mom and tell her about it. You start doing the math in your head on the drive home, calculating exactly how much you would save if you just made this your regular egg source.
For people living within a reasonable driving distance of Coalgate, that math tends to work out pretty favorably. Fresh eggs at a price that almost nobody expects – that is the kind of thing that earns a store a loyal following fast.
Fried Pies That People Drive Miles to Grab
Ask almost anyone who has been to Troyer’s what they remember most, and there is a very good chance the answer involves fried pies. Handmade and packed with filling, these pastries have developed a reputation that extends well beyond Coal County.
Visitors consistently describe them as some of the best they have ever tasted – high praise in a state where fried pies are taken seriously.
The flavors range from fruit varieties to chocolate, and every version reportedly delivers on the filling front. Nobody is going home with a sad, mostly-dough pocket here.
The chocolate gets mentioned often, and the fruit options earn equal loyalty from repeat visitors who claim to work their way through the flavor lineup over multiple trips.
One visitor even ranked them above the well-known Arbuckle Fried Pies, which is a bold claim in Oklahoma fried pie culture. Another mentioned that arriving late on a Saturday afternoon means risking a sellout, particularly on the popular “seven sisters” pie variety.
The lesson is clear: get there early if the fried pies are your mission. Cleanliness and quiet inside the store make the whole experience feel unhurried, like you have all the time in the world to pick your flavor.
Amish-Made Breads and Baked Goods on the Shelf
Bread from a grocery store is usually an afterthought. Bread from Troyer’s is apparently a reason to plan your whole shopping trip.
Visitors frequently mention the Amish-made loaves as a highlight, describing them as the kind of bread that reminds you what the real thing is supposed to taste like.
The baking tradition behind these loaves comes from the same Amish community roots that gave the store its character. No preservatives, no industrial shortcuts – just bread made the way it has been made for generations.
Regulars tend to stock up when they visit, knowing that this is not something they can replicate with a trip to a chain supermarket.
Beyond the standard loaves, the baked goods selection at Troyer’s extends to other homemade treats that visitors describe as little surprises worth discovering. Summer sausage, homemade jams, jellies, and peach preserves have all been mentioned by shoppers who were clearly not expecting to find this level of handcrafted food inside what is technically a discount grocery.
The overall baked goods section functions almost like a small farmers market tucked inside a store, and that unexpected quality is a big part of why first-time visitors tend to become repeat customers almost immediately.
Cheese and Meat Prices That Make Grocery Shopping Fun Again
Cheese gets its own fan base at Troyer’s, and that is not something you hear often about a grocery store in the middle of rural Oklahoma. Visitors single out the cheese selection as one of the store’s consistent strengths, with prices that make stocking up feel like an obvious decision rather than an indulgence.
Meat pricing earns similar enthusiasm. Shoppers describe the deals on cuts and packaged meats as genuinely impressive, with the caveat that some items may be frozen and past their printed date.
One regular visitor noted that cooking the meat promptly after thawing has never caused any issues, and the savings make it well worth the minor adjustment in how you plan meals for the week.
For anyone who has watched grocery bills climb steadily over the past few years, finding a place where cheese and meat are priced the way they used to be feels like a small act of rebellion against inflation. The key is treating it like a treasure hunt rather than a standard shopping run – you do not always know exactly what will be available, but what you find is almost always priced in a way that makes you want to load up the cart.
Regulars seem to have mastered this approach completely.
Name Brands at Prices That Feel Like a Typo
Finding Enjoy Life cookies for 99 cents when they normally sell for around five dollars at big retailers is the kind of discovery that makes you immediately text your friends. Troyer’s operates as a true discount grocery, which means name-brand products often show up at prices that seem like someone made a mistake on the label.
The discount model works because the store sources items that are overstock, close to their best-by dates, or part of Amazon return lots. One visitor described finding a mouse pad in a box of Amazon returns for just a dollar, which gives you a sense of how varied and genuinely surprising the inventory can be on any given day.
Some items may be slightly past their “good till” date, which is standard for discount grocers and a trade-off that regular shoppers understand and accept. The savings more than compensate for the need to shop with a slightly more attentive eye.
Fresh peaches described as perfectly ripe, name-brand snacks at a fraction of retail price, and grocery staples that cost far less than they would anywhere else – Troyer’s essentially turns the weekly grocery run into something that feels like a scavenger hunt with real financial rewards waiting at the checkout.
Homemade Jams, Jellies, and Preserves Worth Stocking Up On
Peach jam, fruit jellies, and homemade preserves line the shelves at Troyer’s in a way that makes the store feel like a crossover between a discount grocer and a country fair vendor booth. Visitors mention the jams and jellies as standout finds, the kind of handcrafted pantry staples that are increasingly hard to come by at a fair price anywhere else.
Peach gets called out specifically, which makes sense given Oklahoma’s affection for the fruit. A jar of good homemade peach preserves is the sort of thing that makes a simple breakfast feel like something worth slowing down for.
Spread on a slice of Amish-made bread from the same store and you have a combination that is hard to improve upon.
The jams and jellies also make excellent gifts for anyone who appreciates food that was actually made by hand rather than assembled on an industrial line. Visitors who stop in on road trips frequently mention picking up multiple jars to bring home, treating them as souvenirs that happen to taste exceptional.
For a store that does not advertise itself heavily, Troyer’s has quietly built a reputation as one of the better sources for this kind of handcrafted pantry staple in southeastern Oklahoma.
The Friendly Staff That Goes Above and Beyond
Friendly staff gets mentioned in Troyer’s reviews almost as often as the fried pies, which is saying something. The people who work here have earned a reputation for genuine warmth rather than the performative kind – visitors consistently describe feeling welcomed and cared for in a way that is increasingly rare in retail settings of any size.
One story stands out particularly. A shopper caught in a severe storm with tornado warnings pulled into the Troyer’s parking lot after hours, scared and unsure what to do.
A man and his son who were still on the property let the family inside to wait out the danger safely. That kind of decency, extended to a stranger after closing time, is not something you can manufacture with a customer service script.
Regulars describe the staff as people who genuinely care about the community they serve, and that feeling comes through even on a first visit. Multiple visitors mention the staff’s kindness as a primary reason they plan to return.
In a small rural area where businesses live and fall on word of mouth, that reputation for warmth is worth more than any advertising budget. Troyer’s has clearly understood this from the beginning, and it shows in how people talk about the place.
Fishing Tackle, Gifts, and Surprises You Did Not Expect to Find
Walk into Troyer’s expecting a grocery store and you will walk out having discovered something closer to a rural general store from a different era. Fishing tackle sits alongside homemade greeting cards, gift items share shelf space with summer sausage, and somewhere in a box of Amazon returns there might be exactly the random item you did not know you needed.
Visitors have described the inventory as a genuine mix of surprises – the kind of place where you go in for eggs and leave with a jar of jam, a fried pie, some fishing lures, and a handmade card for someone’s birthday. The variety feels organic rather than curated, which gives the store a personality that no corporate grocery chain could replicate even if it tried.
For road-trippers passing through southeastern Oklahoma, this eclecticism is part of the charm. Souvenirs, practical goods, handcrafted items, and discounted name brands all coexist in a space that operates on its own logic.
One visitor specifically mentioned the geocache hidden somewhere on the property, which adds a layer of adventure for anyone who enjoys that hobby. Between the unexpected inventory and the possibility of a hidden cache, Troyer’s offers more reasons to linger than most stores twice its size.
The Store’s Connection to the Clarita Area and Amish Auction
Troyer’s sits close enough to the Clarita community that the two have become connected in the minds of regular visitors. Clarita, a small unincorporated community in Coal County, has historically been home to a modest Amish presence, and Troyer’s grew out of that same community fabric.
One event that loyal visitors specifically flag is the Clarita Amish School Auction, held annually on the second Saturday in September in the pasture east of Troyer’s Grocery. For anyone interested in Amish craftsmanship, community culture, or simply a genuinely different kind of Oklahoma event, this auction represents a rare opportunity.
Items at these auctions typically include handmade quilts, woodwork, baked goods, and other handcrafted products made by members of the community.
Pairing a visit to the auction with a stop at Troyer’s makes for a full and memorable day in a part of Oklahoma that most people overlook entirely. The Clarita Greenhouse is another nearby stop worth adding to the itinerary, particularly for plant enthusiasts who appreciate a well-stocked greenhouse run by the local Amish community.
This small cluster of destinations in Coal County offers something genuinely different from the more heavily trafficked parts of the state, and Troyer’s serves as an excellent anchor for the whole experience.
What the Store Looks and Feels Like Inside
Clean, quiet, and unpretentious – those three words come up repeatedly when visitors describe the inside of Troyer’s. The store is not trying to impress anyone with elaborate displays or flashy signage.
What it offers instead is a well-organized space where you can actually browse without feeling overwhelmed or rushed.
Parking is described as plentiful, which matters more than it sounds when you are pulling off a county road with a truck bed you plan to fill. The layout keeps things simple and navigable, and the overall atmosphere feels closer to a well-kept farmstand than a conventional grocery store.
There is a quietness to the place that many visitors find genuinely appealing, especially anyone who finds big-box grocery shopping stressful.
The cleanliness gets specifically mentioned in multiple visitor accounts, which is a detail worth noting for a store that deals in discounted and near-date goods. Maintaining a clean, organized environment while operating a discount model takes real effort, and Troyer’s clearly puts that effort in.
For first-time visitors, the experience tends to land somewhere between charming and unexpectedly impressive – a small store that has figured out exactly what it wants to be and executes on that vision consistently, every day it opens its doors.
Hours, Pricing, and Everything You Need Before You Go
Planning a visit to Troyer’s requires a little advance thought, mostly because the hours are more limited than what most shoppers are used to. The store is open Tuesday through Saturday, 9 AM to 5:30 PM, and closed on Sundays and Mondays.
That closing time of 5:30 PM is firm – one visitor’s review specifically mentions that the store closes at 5:30 sharp, so plan accordingly and give yourself enough time to browse without rushing.
Pricing across the store is structured to deliver genuine value, from the five-dollar 18-egg cartons to deeply discounted name-brand packaged goods. Meat and cheese prices are described as impressive by regulars, and the homemade baked goods are priced in line with what you would expect from a small community operation rather than a specialty food shop.
For navigation, the phone number is 580-258-8686 if you want to call ahead. The store is located at 37097 CR 1730, Coalgate, OK 74538, and GPS will get you there, though the final stretch along the county road requires a bit of attention.
Arriving mid-morning on a weekday tends to give you the best selection, especially if fried pies and fresh baked items are on your list. Weekday mornings also mean a quieter, more relaxed shopping experience overall.
Who Should Make the Trip Out Here
Budget-conscious shoppers are the obvious audience for Troyer’s, but the store’s appeal runs broader than just people watching their grocery bills. Road-trippers cutting through southeastern Oklahoma, homesteaders looking for quality eggs and staple goods at honest prices, and anyone with a soft spot for handmade food and community-rooted businesses will all find something worth the detour here.
Families with kids will appreciate the fried pies as a snack stop that feels like a genuine treat rather than a gas station compromise. Foodies who care about where their bread and cheese come from will find the Amish-made products genuinely interesting.
And anyone who has grown tired of the sterile, impersonal experience of big-box grocery shopping will find Troyer’s to be a refreshing reminder that shopping can still feel human.
The drive itself is part of the draw for the right kind of traveler. Southeastern Oklahoma’s rolling countryside, quiet county roads, and unhurried pace make the approach to Troyer’s feel like a reward rather than an errand.
If you are the type of person who finds joy in discovering a place that most people have never heard of, and you leave with a car full of deals and a bag of fried pies, you are going to be very happy you made the turn. This store rewards curiosity generously.
Share this story
