Some of the best finds in Oklahoma sit at the end of a quiet county road, far from any billboard. I went looking for cheap groceries and drove home with a cooler full of meat, a loaf of fresh bread, and a fried pie I am still thinking about.
The prices made me double-check the receipt, and the people made me want to come back. If you love a bargain with a side of small-town kindness, this little country store is worth the drive.
A Country Store Tucked Away Near Clarita
Out where the pavement thins and pastures roll on for miles, Troyer’s Discount Grocery waits at 37097 CR 1730 near Coalgate, Oklahoma. The store sits in the Clarita area of Coal County, a farming corner of the state where you are more likely to pass cattle than traffic lights.
Visitors often describe it as a stop in the middle of nowhere, and they mean that as a compliment. The building is simple, the setting is peaceful, and the shelves are packed with deals that feel almost too good for the price tags.
One longtime fan even wished for a plain sign out on the state highway so more travelers would know where to turn.
At heart, Troyer’s is a discount grocery, sometimes called a bent and dent store. That means you will find name-brand goods marked way down, frozen meats priced to move, and a surprising mix of homemade treats tied to the local Amish community.
Shoppers come for groceries and leave with stories.
Getting there takes a little effort, but that is half the charm. Think of it as a treasure hunt where the treasure is a full freezer and a lighter wallet strain.
Amish Roots in Coal County
Long before anyone posted about bargains online, word about this store spread the old-fashioned way, from one neighbor to the next. Regulars say the Amish community around Clarita is a big part of what makes the place feel welcoming, and many shoppers mention feeling at home the moment they walk in.
Reviewers note that a man named James and Amish families have helped run the store. That connection shows up on the shelves in the form of homemade breads, cheeses, jams, and the famous fried pies.
Not everyone sees it exactly the same way, though. One shopper felt the store now leans more toward discounted store goods than traditional Amish items and pointed out that the nearby Amish Greenhouse in Clarita still has a small shop inside.
Fair enough, since tastes and memories differ.
Still, most visitors describe a blend that works: everyday discount groceries alongside handmade goodies with country roots. It is a mix you rarely find in a chain store.
For travelers curious about rural Oklahoma life, the store offers a small, friendly window into a close-knit community that values hard work, humble living, and good food made by hand.
Meat Prices That Make the Trip Worth It
Ask a frugal shopper why they keep driving out to Troyer’s, and the answer often lands on the meat counter. One recent visitor summed it up simply: the meat prices are awesome.
Others mention that meats and cheeses here sell at true discount rates.
Here is how it works. As a discount grocer, Troyer’s sometimes carries frozen meats that are past the printed date.
A longtime customer explained that they cook those items as soon as they thaw and have never had a problem. With prices like these, that shopper called the store a blessing.
Fresh pork sausage and summer sausage also earn shout-outs from visitors. Those are the kinds of items that turn a simple breakfast or snack tray into something special.
If you are feeding a big family or stocking a deep freezer, this is the place to plan around. Bring a cooler with ice packs, especially in warm months, since the drive home can be a long one.
A little common sense goes a long way. Check packages, freeze what you will not use soon, and cook thawed meat promptly.
Follow those habits, and your grocery budget may stretch further than you thought possible.
Fried Pies with a Loyal Following
Forget the meat for one moment, because the fried pies might steal the whole show. They are the single most talked-about item at Troyer’s, and fans do not hold back.
One shopper called them the best they have ever had, and another said they were over the top whether eaten hot or cold.
So what makes them special? Visitors rave about the generous filling inside every flavor.
Chocolate gets plenty of love, and so do the fruit options. Peach shows up in conversations too, which makes sense in a state that loves a good peach.
One loyal fan even claimed these pies beat the well-known Arbuckle Fried Pies by a mile. That is bold talk in Oklahoma, where fried pies are practically a road trip tradition.
Shoppers recommend grabbing several flavors so you can taste-test on the drive home. Some mention a sought-after brand called 7 sisters’ pies, which can sell out by late afternoon on a busy Saturday.
Here is a friendly tip: arrive earlier in the day if pies are your top goal. Nobody wants to drive down a county road only to find an empty pie shelf waiting for them.
Cheese, Butter, and Homemade Breads
Picture a loaf of fresh-baked bread sitting next to a thick wedge of farm-style cheese. That simple pairing is exactly what many shoppers carry out the door at Troyer’s.
Cheese comes up again and again in visitor comments. One regular said the store has the best cheese and butter around, while another happily listed Amish-made cheese among their haul.
If you like slicing a block for sandwiches or snacking, you will want to browse this section slowly.
The breads earn praise too. Shoppers describe them as yummy and mention picking up Amish baked bread to enjoy at home.
Homemade loaves have a different texture than the soft packaged kind, and that difference is what keeps folks coming back.
Baked goods beyond bread show up as well, offering little sweet surprises for anyone with a snack craving. Visitors have called these the kind of treats you will be glad you stopped for.
Put it all together and you have the makings of a picnic. Grab some bread, cheese, and summer sausage, then find a shady spot on the way home.
Few meals feel more Oklahoma country than that, and it costs far less than eating out.
Jams, Jellies, and Sweet Little Extras
Shiny jars lined up on a shelf have a way of tempting even the most careful shopper. At Troyer’s, homemade jams and jellies are part of that sweet temptation.
Visitors mention them alongside the fried pies and fresh sausage as reasons to stop. A spoonful of homemade jam on warm bread is one of those small joys that makes a regular breakfast feel like Sunday morning at a farmhouse.
The store also carries what one shopper called little Amish treats. Think small, homemade goodies that are easy to toss into the cart and even easier to finish before you reach the highway.
Jams and jellies also make fantastic gifts. Bringing a jar back to a friend or neighbor is a thoughtful way to share your road trip without spending much.
They travel well too, which matters when you are miles from home.
Fruit lovers should keep an eye out for fresh produce as well. One visitor once found perfectly ripe peaches that tasted delicious.
Availability changes, so treat each visit like a fresh hunt. You never know which flavors will be stacked on the shelf, and that sense of surprise is part of the fun.
Fresh Eggs at a Farm-Friendly Price
Egg prices have given plenty of families sticker shock in recent years. That is what makes one shopper’s report from Troyer’s stand out: real fresh eggs, about five dollars for an 18-count carton.
The same visitor walked away with Amish baked bread and Amish-made cheese too. That is a pretty impressive bag of basics for a modest amount of money.
Fresh eggs taste different from the standard grocery kind. Many people notice richer yolks and a better flavor in scrambles, biscuits, and baking.
If you cook a lot at home, that difference adds up quickly.
Of course, prices can change over time, so treat that number as a snapshot rather than a promise. The bigger point is that this store keeps everyday staples within reach for budget-minded families in rural Oklahoma.
Bundle eggs with discounted meat and homemade bread, and you have covered several meals in one stop. For households trying to stretch each dollar, that kind of value matters a lot.
A handy tip: bring a cooler or insulated bag for the ride home. Eggs, cheese, and meat all appreciate staying cool, especially during a hot Oklahoma summer afternoon.
The Bent and Dent Treasure Hunt
Ninety-nine cents for a box of cookies that usually runs around five dollars elsewhere? One shopper found exactly that with Enjoy Life cookies at Troyer’s, and it is a perfect example of how this store works.
Discount grocers like this one buy overstock, slightly dented packages, and items near or slightly past their good-till dates. Visitors say they find quality name brands at super cheap prices, which is music to any frugal ear.
The selection goes beyond food. One shopper needed a mouse pad and found one in a big box of Amazon returns for just a dollar.
Moments like that turn a grocery run into a real treasure hunt.
Because inventory depends on what comes in, the shelves change from visit to visit. That keeps regulars curious and coming back often.
You might find your favorite cereal one week and a surprise snack brand the next.
A smart approach is to arrive with a loose list and an open mind. Stock up when you spot a great deal on something you use often.
Check dates and packaging as you shop, and the savings can be impressive for families everywhere.
Gifts, Cards, and Fishing Tackle Under One Roof
Not every grocery store sells handmade greeting cards right next to fishing lures. Troyer’s does, and that quirky mix is part of its country charm.
Visitors have mentioned homemade cards described as beautiful, plus gifts and souvenirs that make easy keepsakes from a day in the countryside. If you need a last-minute birthday card with a personal touch, this might be a better choice than a generic drugstore option.
Fishing tackle also appears on the shelves, which fits the outdoor spirit of southeastern Oklahoma. Anglers heading to a local pond or lake could grab supplies along with snacks for the day.
Shoppers sum up the range as grocery items and so much more. One visitor praised the large variety, noting how many fresh, tasty items came from Amish hands.
That variety makes the store fun to wander. Take a slow lap around the aisles before heading to the register, because you could easily miss a hidden gem on a lower shelf.
Picking up a small souvenir is a sweet way to remember the trip. A handmade card or jar of jam says you found something real, far off the usual tourist path.
Kindness That Lasts Past Closing Time
Storm clouds were rolling in, tornado warnings were sounding, and one mother was driving home with her kids. Scared, she pulled into the Troyer’s parking lot after hours.
A gentleman and his son were still there, and they let the family inside to wait out the weather. She later shared that their customer service does not stop at closing time, and she was deeply grateful they kept her children safe.
Stories like that explain why friendly staff is one of the most talked-about things about this store. Shoppers describe the people as super nice, sweet, and caring.
Several say the workers truly care about their customers, not just their sales.
Cashiers get kind words too, with visitors calling them warm and friendly. Many shoppers say they felt welcome from the first visit and plan to return.
In a world of self-checkouts and rushed lines, that kind of attention feels rare. It is easy to find cheap groceries online, but it is much harder to find people who would open their doors during a storm.
Bargains bring folks in the first time. Kindness like this is what turns them into lifelong regulars across Oklahoma.
Clean Aisles and a Quiet Pit Stop
Road-trippers know the value of a good pit stop. Clean, quiet, and roomy enough to park without stress, Troyer’s checks those boxes, according to visitors.
Cleanliness is a frequent compliment here. Shoppers notice tidy aisles and a well-kept space, which matters a lot at a discount store where some people expect clutter.
Instead, the store feels orderly and calm.
The quiet is part of the appeal. Without loud music or crowds pushing carts, you can browse at your own pace.
It is a nice change from big-box stores where every trip feels like a race.
Plenty of parking makes the stop easy, even for travelers pulling larger vehicles. That is handy if you are exploring backroads and need a break to stretch your legs.
Families with kids might enjoy the relaxed setting too. Little ones can help pick out a fried pie flavor without getting lost in a giant maze of aisles.
For anyone who loves rural drives, this store is a natural stop. Grab a snack, use the time to recharge, and head back out feeling refreshed.
Simple places like this make Oklahoma road trips more memorable.
Nearby Greenhouse, Auction Days, and a Hidden Geocache
Smart travelers stack their stops, and the Clarita area makes that easy. One regular says Troyer’s is a must-visit every time they head to the Clarita Greenhouse, an Amish greenhouse known for its plants.
Another visitor confirmed the greenhouse has a small store inside and is a great spot to buy plants. Pairing the two creates a lovely half-day outing, especially in spring when gardens are on everyone’s mind.
Mark your calendar for something extra special too. A shopper shared that the Clarita Amish School Auction is held on the second Saturday in September, in the pasture east of Troyer’s.
Events like this can be a fun way to experience rural community life up close.
Here is a quirky bonus for adventure lovers. According to a visitor, a geocache is hidden at the store.
If you enjoy geocaching, bring your app and add a little scavenger hunt to your shopping trip.
Between plants, auctions, and hidden treasures, the area rewards curious explorers. It is the kind of corner of Oklahoma that feels made for slow travel.
Confirm event details locally before you go, since schedules can shift from year to year.
Hours, Phone, and Planning Your Drive
Timing matters out here, so plan ahead. Troyer’s Discount Grocery is open Monday through Saturday from 9 AM to 5:30 PM.
The store is closed on Sunday.
One visitor pointed out that they close by 5:30 sharp. If you are driving in from a distance, give yourself a cushion so you are not racing the clock down a county road.
The address is 37097 CR 1730, Coalgate, OK 74538. Because the store sits in a rural spot, it helps to use GPS and check your route before leaving.
Cell signals can be spotty in the countryside, so saving directions ahead of time is a smart move.
Want to call before heading out? The phone number is 580-258-8686.
A quick call can help you check on items, especially popular ones like fried pies.
Saturday afternoons can mean some favorites sell out, so mornings may be your best bet. One shopper learned that lesson when a pie brand was gone by late afternoon.
Pack a cooler, bring reusable bags, and leave room in the trunk. Most visitors find themselves buying more than planned, and that is part of the fun.
A Humble Stop Worth Going Out of Your Way For
Sometimes the best places are the ones nobody advertises. Troyer’s Discount Grocery proves that a simple building on a quiet county road can win the hearts of shoppers from all over.
Frugal families come for the meat prices and name-brand bargains. They return for the fried pies, homemade bread, cheese, and jams.
Many say they stay loyal because of the warm, caring people behind the counter.
One shopper who spent a year living in Michigan said finding this store felt like a real blessing. Another playfully called it the greatest store on the planet.
Big words for a small shop, but many regulars seem to agree with the spirit.
Not everything will suit every visitor. Some items are discount goods near their dates, and the Amish selection may feel different than it once did.
Shop with realistic expectations, and the value usually shines through.
If you love rural drives, budget wins, and homemade treats, this stop deserves a spot on your Oklahoma list. Bring a cooler and an appetite.
You may leave with a full trunk, a happy belly, and a new favorite place to tell friends about.
Share this story
