I went looking for a quick bag of tomatoes and ended up sitting on a picnic bench with a pie on my lap, staring at a field of sunflowers. That is the kind of surprise waiting at Youngs Farm, a quiet country market on Long Island in New York.
From the outside it looks like a simple barn shop, but the bakery case, the soups, and the flower fields turn a short errand into a whole afternoon. If you love fresh food and slow days outside, keep reading.
A Barn-Style Market on a Quiet Glen Head Lane

Tucked along Hegemans Lane in Glen Head, Youngs Farm sits so peacefully that one visitor said you forget you are even in New York. The address is 91 Hegemans Ln, close to Oyster Bay on the North Shore of Long Island.
So what exactly is it? Picture a longtime working farm with an on-site country market and bakery under one barn-like roof.
Inside, shoppers find pies, fresh produce, breads, soups, and plenty of prepared foods to carry home.
Guests often describe the store as a small, eclectic shop with distinct areas. One section holds fruits and vegetables, another is full of cute gifts, and a third covers dairy and other food items.
Outside, rows of blooms and tall shade trees frame the property. Regulars call the whole place charming, well kept, and calm, which makes even a quick stop feel like a tiny countryside escape without a long road trip.
Roots That Run Through Generations of Shoppers

Seventeen years. That is how long one fan says she has been visiting, starting when she was very young, and she claims her memories of the farm could fill an encyclopedia.
During summer, she admits to stopping in every single day.
Stories like that are common here. Families mention coming back for so many years that walking through the door still makes them feel like kids in a candy store, happy and excited every time.
Part of that loyalty comes from the people behind the counter. Regulars say staff members remember their names and seem genuinely glad to see them, so the market feels like a second home.
First-timers get the same warmth too. A nervous newcomer shared that a young employee patiently explained how everything worked, while the rest of the team offered smiles and greetings.
That kind of welcome helps explain why a farm stand becomes a family tradition.
Pies Worth the Drive

Ask around about this farm and pies come up more than anything else. They are clearly the star of the bakery, and visitors talk about them with the kind of excitement usually saved for holidays.
One cheerful reviewer described turning the corner inside the market and spotting pies on the bakery shelves, then finding even more in the refrigerated and frozen section. Their reaction was basically pure drooling, twice over.
Fans praise the baked goods as homemade and consistently delicious. Some shoppers say literally every pastry they have tried has been good, which is high praise for a place with so much variety.
Here is a tip worth borrowing. Grab a pie, head out the back door, and settle onto a bench near the flower fields.
Eating a fresh slice under tall shade trees while sunflowers sway nearby turns dessert into a memory your family will keep asking to repeat.
Scones, Breads, and the Rest of the Bakery Case

Cranberry scone lovers, take note. One visitor called it truly the best they had ever eaten, and scones get repeated shout-outs from other guests as well.
Beyond pies, the bakery case stretches into muffins, cakes, cookies, and breads. Shoppers have raved about a soft loaf with olives baked right in, plus a delicious sesame seed bread that went home for family dinner.
Sweet tooth? Cheesecake carrot cake cupcakes have earned happy reviews too.
Cookies are another highlight, and one self-described cookie monster said the gluten-free ones were among the best they had ever tried.
Speaking of dietary needs, regulars point out that several gluten-free items are available, which makes it easier for mixed groups to share a treat. Even a home baker who makes sourdough, baguettes, and pastries says this bakery is the real deal.
When serious bakers approve, you know the ovens here are doing something right.
Soups, Juices, and Grab-and-Go Comfort

Soup might be the sleeper hit. It ranks among the most talked-about items, and shoppers love bringing a container outside to the picnic tables beside the store.
The prepared food selection goes well beyond a single pot. Guests mention vegetarian chili, spinach dip, fresh mozzarella, cheeses, and refrigerated and frozen meals that help stock a home kitchen for the week.
Thirsty? Freshly made juice is one of the newer additions, and a carrot ginger blend earned praise for being smooth and sweet with a little spice.
Another visitor called the vanilla cream soda the best they had ever had, and no-sugar-added apple cider shows up in the fall.
The team even builds care packages. One customer ordered soups, muffins, breads, and Brie online for a family going through a hard time, and a staff member called to confirm and wrapped everything individually.
Thoughtful touches like that bring real comfort.
Organic Rows and Honest Sourcing

Out in the fields and greenhouses, the farm grows over 40 different types of organic fruits and vegetables across the year. Mixed greens, arugula, baby kale, basil, head lettuce, carrots, and radishes are part of the lineup.
Not everything comes from Glen Head soil, though. The farm openly shares that it supplements its stock with produce from other Long Island farms, plus growers in New England and Pennsylvania, and labels sources as clearly as possible.
As the season moves into summer and fall, more local harvests fill the bins. Shoppers have carried home heirloom tomatoes for caprese salads and pumpkins during autumn visits.
A curious visitor once met the farm manager in the field. He took time to explain the organic methods and how the team was testing heirloom seeds to see what thrives best.
Moments like that show a farm that cares about learning, not just selling.
Sunflowers, Zinnias, and Picnic Benches

Bright yellow faces turned toward the sun greet guests as they pull in. Rows of sunflowers and colorful zinnias line the land, and photographers of every age stop to snap pictures.
Families find it an easy place to bring children. Kids can stroll beside the sunflower field, then everyone gathers for a laid-back picnic with the goodies just picked up inside.
Seating is simple but lovely. There are picnic tables by the side of the store and benches out back that overlook the flower fields under tall shady trees.
One guest painted a sweet picture of what might pop up during lunch. Playful birds, a curious striped kitten, or farm hands working the greenhouses could all appear while sunbeams drift across the table.
It is the sort of scene that reminds you why slowing down matters, especially with a fork in one hand and pie in the other.
Gift Shelves for Every Occasion

Teacher Appreciation Week turned into a small triumph for one parent. She came in with a few ideas, and a member of the bakery team arranged and wrapped gifts so beautifully that the teachers were wowed.
Gifts are a big part of the market’s charm. Shelves hold ceramic cookware, table runners, tablecloths, decorative dish towels, hand soap, aprons, and seasonal holiday knick-knacks.
Pantry treats make great presents too. Look for jams, honey, pickled foods, sauces, spices, apple butter, and salted caramel, along with cute extras like spreaders.
Shoppers often say the pieces feel tasteful and carefully chosen. One fan called the whole curation genius, noting how every small detail seems thoughtfully planned.
Whether you need a hostess gift, a holiday basket, or a little something for yourself, browsing these shelves can easily take longer than expected, in the best possible way.
Planning Your Visit and the Final Word

Good news for planners: the market opens every day of the week from 10 AM to 5 PM. Free on-site parking makes arrival easy, and two cashier areas help folks in a hurry get moving.
Weekends can get crowded, so a weekday morning may feel more relaxed. Call ahead at 516-626-3955 or check youngs.farm for updates.
Budget wisely, since some guests find prices on the steep side. One shopper paid $8 a pound for tomatoes and felt it was too much.
Others explain that organic growing costs more and say the quality and service make it worthwhile.
So is it worth the trip? For pie lovers, picnic fans, and anyone craving a slower afternoon, the answer leans toward yes.
Pick up a slice, find a shady bench, and let the sunflowers do the rest.
Share this story

