A whole slice of pie gets blended into a milkshake at one roadside stop along Lake Superior. That single fact was enough to make me hungry for the rest of the story.
The bakery has been rolling out homestyle pies since 1956. Its pie list runs from coconut cream to bumbleberry to a five-layer chocolate creation that sounds like a friendly dare.
I like how the place keeps its schedule short and sweet. Doors open only on weekends, with retro booths inside and picnic tables outside looking toward the big lake.
I can’t imagine cruising the North Shore of Minnesota without pulling over here at least once, especially with a cooler waiting in the trunk. So which slice would you claim first, and would you be brave enough to drink the second one?
A Pie Shop Waiting Right Off Highway 61
Roadside pie legends rarely sit this close to the pavement. Betty’s Pies rests right off Highway 61, just before you roll into Two Harbors on Minnesota’s North Shore.
The shop calls itself a bakeshop and American eatery. That means you can grab a slice to go or settle into a booth for a full breakfast or lunch.
Location is half the charm here. The drive from Duluth already hugs Lake Superior, so the stop feels like a natural reward for keeping your eyes on that blue horizon.
Getting there takes zero detective work. The shop sits along the main route, and a big parking lot greets travelers who spot the sign and suddenly remember they need pie.
North Shore road trippers often treat this as their first real pause after leaving the city. Families heading toward cabins, campgrounds, and waterfalls tend to plan around it rather than stumble on it.
Minnesota has plenty of scenic highways. Very few of them come with a bakery that has been feeding hungry drivers for nearly seven decades, which feels like a quiet win for the whole state.
Nearly Seventy Years Of Rolling Pins
Back in 1956, Betty’s Pies started baking on the North Shore. That makes it a veteran bakery with roots older than most of the cars now filling its lot.
Longevity like that is a big deal in Minnesota. Small-town spots that last this long usually do so by sticking to what works and resisting the urge to chase every trend.
Homestyle pies remain the heart of the operation. The kitchen still focuses on classic flavors that feel familiar, the kind a grandparent might have set on the counter after Sunday supper.
Old rolling pins hang on the walls inside, a fitting tribute to all that dough. It’s a simple decorating choice, yet it tells the story of the place better than any plaque could.
Generations of Minnesotans have made this stop part of their summer rituals. Some kids who once begged for a slice now bring their own kids, which keeps the tradition humming along.
History here doesn’t feel stuffy or museum-like. It feels lived in, flour-dusted, and very much open for business every weekend.
Retro Booths That Feel Like 1960
Slide into a booth and the decades start melting away. The dining room leans hard into old-school diner style, with retro booths that look ready for a jukebox soundtrack.
Little touches make it fun to look around. Hand-painted condiment holders sit on the tables, and those rolling pins on the walls keep the bakery theme front and center.
Families tend to love this kind of room. It’s casual enough for wiggly toddlers yet charming enough that grandparents feel right at home with their coffee.
The overall mood lands somewhere between cozy cabin and classic soda fountain. That mix suits the North Shore, where travelers often arrive sun-tired and craving something comforting.
You won’t find white tablecloths or fussy plating. Big-city restaurants can keep their minimalist concrete walls, because this room proves warmth beats trendiness every time.
Booths do fill up quickly on busy weekends. Still, once you snag one, the setting makes it easy to linger over a second slice without anyone rushing you out the door.
Coconut Cream And Its Fluffy Fan Club
Coconut cream ranks among the most talked-about slices at Betty’s Pies. It’s a classic cream pie, the kind that has quietly anchored diner dessert cases across Minnesota for generations.
Cream pies here earn steady attention. They often draw more love than the fruit options, which says plenty about how well the shop handles a silky filling.
Indecision is a real hazard at the counter. One young diner couldn’t choose between coconut cream and key lime, and a kind server simply brought both slices to the table.
That small gesture captures the spirit of the place. Hospitality and pie go hand in hand, and nobody makes you feel silly for wanting more than one flavor.
Coconut cream also travels surprisingly well in a to-go box. Plenty of road trippers carry a slice to a cabin or hotel room for a late-night treat.
Should you order it first or save it for last? Either way, it makes a strong case for being the slice your whole crew ends up sharing with forks flying.
Bumbleberry, Rhubarb, And A Fruit Lineup Worth Tasting
Bumbleberry might be the most fun word on the menu. It’s a mixed-berry fruit pie that balances sweet and tart without leaning too hard either way.
Strawberry rhubarb is another heavy hitter. Rhubarb practically counts as a Minnesota backyard staple, so seeing it starring in a pie feels like a nod to every family garden in the state.
Raspberry rhubarb joins the party with a strudel-style top crust. That crumbly finish gives it a little extra crunch compared to the classic double-crust slices.
French blueberry, cherry, and caramel apple round out the fruit side. A gluten-free apple caramel option may also appear, which is welcome news for anyone avoiding wheat.
Fruit selections can shift with what the kitchen has on hand. Popular flavors sometimes sell out, so having a backup choice in mind is a smart move.
Fans of tart, juicy slices will find plenty to explore. Pair a fruit pie with a cream pie, split them down the middle, and call it a well-rounded afternoon.
Chocolate Towers And Toffee Temptations
Five layers of chocolate in one slice sounds almost unreasonable. The 5 Layer Chocolate pie at Betty’s Pies happily ignores reason and stacks the flavor sky-high.
Toffee cream brings a different kind of indulgence. Its pale, shortbread-like crust holds a light, sweet filling studded with crunchy toffee bits that keep every bite interesting.
French silk offers another route for chocolate lovers. It leans rich and smooth, a reliable pick for anyone who considers fruit pie a waste of perfectly good dessert space.
The candy-bar crowd also gets attention. Butterfinger and Oreo cream pies show up on the lineup, turning familiar snacks into full-blown diner desserts.
Chocolate banana cream and French cherry cream add even more variety. It’s honestly a little overwhelming, in the best way, when you’re staring at the list with a hungry family behind you.
Sweet-tooth travelers should plan accordingly. Ordering one chocolate slice and one toffee slice for the table seems like the most diplomatic solution to a delicious problem.
The Great Lakes Pie Pays Tribute To Home
Naming a pie after the Great Lakes takes some confidence. Betty’s Pies does exactly that, and the Great Lakes pie has become one of its well-known slices.
The name fits the setting perfectly. Lake Superior sits right outside, so ordering it feels a bit like eating a souvenir of the drive itself.
Specialty pies like this help set the shop apart from chain bakeries. You simply can’t grab a Great Lakes slice at a strip-mall dessert counter in the suburbs.
Minnesotans tend to appreciate anything that celebrates their corner of the map. A pie honoring the region’s famous waters is pure North Shore pride on a plate.
Pairing it with something creamy makes for a fun contrast. A tart slice and a smooth slice side by side let you sample both halves of the menu’s personality.
Visitors from out of state often want something they can only get here. This might be the slice that earns bragging rights back home, along with a photo of the lake.
A Whole Slice Blended Into A Shake
Polar Pie Shakes solve a problem nobody knew they had. Why choose between pie and a milkshake when the kitchen will blend an entire piece of pie into the cup?
The idea sounds gimmicky until you see how many people order one. Lines at the outdoor window often include plenty of folks waiting specifically for these shakes.
Pick a favorite flavor and the shake takes on its personality. A fruit pie version tastes completely different from a chocolate or cream pie blend, so the options feel endless.
Summer drives along the North Shore make a cold treat extra appealing. Sipping one at a picnic table near Lake Superior is a pretty great way to spend a weekend afternoon.
Kids especially tend to find the concept hilarious. Telling them there’s real pie hiding inside the shake usually earns a wide-eyed grin.
It’s playful, a little over the top, and very Minnesota in its practicality. Dessert gets combined into one tidy package that fits nicely in a car cup holder.
Hearty Plates Before The Dessert Course
Pie gets top billing, yet the kitchen serves a full menu of breakfast and lunch. Classic American comfort food fills the rest of the pages at Betty’s Pies.
Fried chicken dinners come with mashed potatoes and gravy, coleslaw, and a biscuit. Portions run generous, often big enough to share with whoever’s sitting across the booth.
Walleye specials sometimes appear too, which feels just right for the region. Minnesota’s favorite fish on a North Shore plate is about as local as lunch can get.
Hot beef sandwiches, BLTs, chicken pesto sandwiches, and a spicy chicken option round out the choices. Egg salad paired with the soup special may even come with a small side of pie.
Onion rings arrive in a pile that looks almost comical in size. Fries also earn plenty of love, so ordering a basket for the table is rarely a mistake.
Showing up just for dessert is fine. Still, skipping the main menu means missing half the reason families keep coming back with empty stomachs.
Grab-And-Go At The Outdoor Window
Not everyone has time for a sit-down meal. That’s exactly why the outdoor ordering and pickup window has become such a favorite feature here.
Travelers can walk up, order a slice or a whole pie, and get back on the road. Staff pack napkins and utensils, so you can enjoy dessert wherever the day leads.
The line stands under a covered area. North Shore weather can turn quickly, so having a roof overhead is a thoughtful touch during a sudden shower.
Busy days can mean a short wait at the window. Even so, the to-go line often moves faster than waiting for a booth inside.
Whole pies make great gifts for cabin hosts or campground neighbors. Few things win friends faster than showing up with a boxed bumbleberry under your arm.
Some travelers even swing by on their return trip for one more pie. Heading home from the Boundary Waters without a box in the back seat apparently feels incomplete to plenty of folks.
Picnic Tables Facing Lake Superior
Lake Superior steals the show outside. Picnic tables give you a spot to eat with a view of the largest of the Great Lakes stretching toward the horizon.
Outdoor seating turns a quick snack into a mini event. Warm weekends invite families to spread out, unwrap their slices, and soak in that famous North Shore breeze.
Big-city patios rarely compete with scenery like this. You’d struggle to find a downtown terrace anywhere with a backdrop this massive and this blue.
Summer and early fall bring the best outdoor days. Cooler months may push most diners indoors, where the cozy booths take over hosting duties.
A slice of pie tastes different with fresh lake air, at least it seems that way. Maybe it’s the scenery, or maybe it’s simply the joy of being up north.
Either way, these tables offer an easy escape from a crowded dining room. Bring a jacket just in case, because Lake Superior likes to keep things refreshingly cool.
Hours, Address, And Nearby North Shore Stops
Plan carefully, because the doors open only two days a week. Betty’s Pies typically serves guests Saturday and Sunday from 9 AM to 6 PM.
Weekdays are currently closed, so a Tuesday craving will need to wait. Hours can change seasonally, so a quick check before driving north is always wise.
You’ll find the shop at 2019, 1633 MN-61, Two Harbors, MN 55616. It sits right off the highway, making it an easy stop on any North Shore itinerary.
Prices feel fair for a full diner meal plus dessert. A slice costs more than grocery store pie, yet the generous plates make the whole visit feel like solid value.
Nearby attractions pair nicely with a pie break. Agate Bay beach sits close by, and Gooseberry Falls makes a lovely place to walk off that second slice.
Merchandise is also available on the way out. A shirt or souvenir lets you rep your favorite Minnesota pie stop long after the crumbs disappear.
Why This Slice Of Minnesota Is Worth The Drive
Some road trips need a sweet anchor. Betty’s Pies fills that role beautifully, offering classic pies, hearty meals, and nearly seventy years of North Shore tradition.
Not every slice will rewrite your idea of dessert. Tastes vary, and the shop simply aims for homestyle comfort rather than fancy pastry theatrics.
That honesty is part of the appeal. It’s a place for families, road trippers, and anyone who loves a retro booth and a fork in hand.
Coconut cream, bumbleberry, toffee, and five-layer chocolate give every visitor a reason to come back. Add pie shakes and fried chicken, and the list keeps growing.
Minnesota wins again with a spot like this. A small-town bakery outshining plenty of big-city dessert bars feels like something worth bragging about to friends in the Twin Cities.
So gas up the car and aim for Highway 61 on a Saturday morning. Tag the friend who always orders two desserts, because this trip deserves a partner in pie.
Share this story
