Unearth The Voyage
Pumpkin season is officially in full swing across New York State – and it’s not just about pies anymore. From creamy cheesecakes to frothy lattes and even pumpkin ice cream sandwiches, these dessert spots are dishing out fall flavor in every bite. Here are 10 must-try pumpkin dessert destinations before Thanksgiving rolls around.
1. Milk Bar – New York City
In the heart of New York City, Milk Bar offers a twist on traditional pumpkin desserts. Their seasonal Pumpkin Dulce de Leche Cake captures the essence of fall with spiced pumpkin layers. Each bite is an exploration of flavors, with milk crumbs adding a delightful crunch.
What makes this cake exceptional is the luscious caramel frosting, making it a modern classic. Milk Bar, known for reinventing American classics, has truly outdone itself with this autumnal masterpiece.
Perfect for those chilly city nights, this cake is a must-try for anyone seeking a sweet escape. You’ll find it hard to resist the allure of this decadent creation.
2. Dottie’s Donuts – Brooklyn
Brooklyn’s own Dottie’s Donuts brings a vegan twist to the pumpkin craze. Their Pumpkin Spice Donut is a seasonal delight, glazed with a cinnamon-sugar coating that hits all the right notes.
Popular among locals, this donut pairs wonderfully with a hot oat-milk latte, capturing the ultimate fall-in-the-city vibe. The shop’s trendy aesthetic and friendly atmosphere make it a cozy spot to enjoy these autumn flavors.
Whether you’re a donut aficionado or a pumpkin enthusiast, Dottie’s has something special in store. It’s a seasonal ritual you won’t want to miss, offering a taste of Brooklyn’s vibrant culinary scene.
3. Buttercup Bake Shop – Manhattan
Nestled in Manhattan, Buttercup Bake Shop crafts a Pumpkin Cupcake with Maple Frosting that has garnered a loyal following. The soft, spiced cake is topped with a buttery, maple-kissed icing that melts in your mouth.
This cupcake is a harmonious blend of fall flavors, creating a delightful experience with every bite. The shop’s cozy atmosphere invites a sense of warmth and nostalgia, perfect for a break from the bustling city.
It’s no wonder this treat has become a staple for locals and visitors alike. A visit to Buttercup is incomplete without indulging in this autumn favorite.
4. Battenkill Valley Creamery – Salem
In the scenic town of Salem, Battenkill Valley Creamery offers a unique take on pumpkin desserts with their Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream. Made with local cream, it’s like enjoying a frozen slice of pumpkin pie.
This small, family-run creamery is known for utilizing fresh, local ingredients, ensuring a rich and authentic flavor. The ice cream captures the spirit of the season perfectly.
For those seeking a taste of nostalgia, this treat provides a comforting reminder of home-baked pies. A visit here is not just for the dessert but also for the warm, welcoming community spirit.
5. Cheesecake Factory – Multiple NY Locations
Across various locations, the Cheesecake Factory offers a seasonal favorite: Pumpkin Cheesecake. This rich, creamy dessert is topped with a generous dollop of whipped cream, making it an indulgent treat.
Known for its photogenic appearance, this cheesecake is a social media favorite and a staple of autumn festivities. Its velvety texture and perfect balance of spices make it a beloved classic.
Whether shared with friends or savored solo, this dessert is sure to delight. A visit to the Cheesecake Factory during the fall wouldn’t be complete without experiencing this creamy masterpiece.
6. The Crisp Cannoli – West Babylon
Long Island’s The Crisp Cannoli reimagines an Italian classic with their Pumpkin Cannoli. Filled with a sweet pumpkin ricotta blend, this treat transforms tradition into an autumnal delight.
The bakery is a local favorite, celebrated for its innovative take on the cannoli. The creamy, spiced filling and crispy shell create a perfect harmony of flavors and textures.
This seasonal treat is an exploration of flavors that will surprise and satisfy. It’s a must-try, offering a taste of Long Island’s vibrant culinary creativity.
7. Purity Ice Cream – Ithaca
Since 1936, Purity Ice Cream in Ithaca has been a beloved destination for sweet treats. Their Pumpkin Ice Cream, made with real pumpkin puree and warm spices, is a seasonal sensation.
This iconic ice cream shop captures the spirit of fall with each scoop, offering a taste of nostalgia to all who visit. The creamy texture and rich flavor make it a standout choice.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this treat provides a comforting escape, embracing the essence of autumn in upstate New York.
8. Village Bake Shoppe – Lewiston
Near the majestic Niagara Falls, Village Bake Shoppe serves a Pumpkin Roll that delights visitors with its light sponge cake and rich cream cheese filling.
Dusted with powdered sugar, this dessert is a visual and flavorful masterpiece. The shop, a hidden gem in Western New York, is cherished for its commitment to quality and tradition.
Visitors flock here not just for the desserts but for the heartwarming hospitality. This pumpkin roll is a signature creation that embodies the warmth of the season.
9. Cider Belly Doughnuts – Albany
Just steps from Albany’s Capitol, Cider Belly Doughnuts specializes in hot, fresh cider doughnuts. However, it’s their Pumpkin Doughnuts that capture the essence of fall.
Soft and spiced, these doughnuts are served warm, enveloping you in a comforting aroma. The shop’s lively atmosphere and friendly service enhance the experience.
An Albany staple, these doughnuts are a celebration of the season. A visit to Cider Belly promises a delightful journey through autumn’s best flavors.
10. Baked – Beacon
In the charming town of Beacon, Baked offers a rustic Pumpkin Bread Pudding that defines cozy indulgence. Served warm with a caramel drizzle, it’s a taste of home.
This Hudson Valley favorite combines traditional flavors with a modern twist, creating a dessert that is both comforting and intriguing. It’s a must-try for anyone exploring the region.
The quaint atmosphere of Baked enhances the experience, making it a beloved stop for locals and tourists. This dessert is the perfect complement to any autumn day.
