One restaurant on this skinny barrier island lives inside a hotel that dates to 1874. Another serves oysters across the long counter of a family-owned raw bar.
I had to read that twice.
Then I kept digging. A Victorian inn serves dinner with piano music.
A rooftop deck at a harbor spot catches the sunset. An Italian dining room is so popular that reservations are a smart move most nights.
I love that none of these places tries too hard to look fancy from the street. Many of them look like simple shore buildings you could cruise past on a summer afternoon in New Jersey.
So I built a list of twelve restaurants worth the trip. Pack a light bag, loosen your schedule, and clear some room in your stomach.
Then tell me, honestly, how many meals can one weekend really hold?
1. Black Eyed Susans Restaurant & Bar
Scallops and iced tea might sound like a simple pairing, but here they arrive with farm-to-table care. The kitchen leans on locally sourced American cooking, with seafood front and center.
You’ll find the restaurant in Harvey Cedars, one of the smaller boroughs on Long Beach Island. The setting feels beachy and relaxed, yet the plates show serious ambition.
So what lands on the table? Octopus salad and tri-tip platters show up among the dishes, alongside small plates and organic options.
Vegetarians get real attention too, thanks to a full vegetarian menu. That makes it an easy pick when your group has mixed appetites and strong opinions.
Timing matters with this one. The restaurant opens for summer, and dinner runs Wednesday through Saturday evenings, starting at 4 PM.
Thursday through Saturday nights tend to be the busiest stretch. Reservations are recommended for dinner, and planning ahead saves you from a hungry scramble.
The dining room has a fireplace, which adds charm on a cooler shore evening. Outdoor seating is available as well, if you’d rather catch the salty breeze.
Service gets plenty of attention here, with hosts, servers, and kitchen staff checking in on tables. That kind of teamwork makes a dinner feel like an occasion instead of a pit stop.
Save room for dessert, since sweets are a strong part of the experience. It’s a fitting first stop on a New Jersey food weekend that’s only getting started.
Address: 7908 Long Beach Blvd, Harvey Cedars, NJ 08008
2. Daymark
Drive north on Long Beach Island until the road basically runs out, and you’ll reach a lobster roll worth the mileage. Barnegat Light sits at the island’s northern tip, and this spot claims a great piece of it.
The menu brings seasonal, globally inspired American fare to the table. That means familiar comfort food can sit right beside something a little more adventurous.
Let’s talk about that lobster roll. It’s packed with fresh, chunky Maine lobster, and the fish sandwiches in general earn plenty of love.
Inside, the room feels bright and artfully decorated. Nautical-themed wood booths and lamps give it a rustic-chic look that suits a harbor town nicely.
Families fit right in, with a kids’ menu and high chairs ready to go. Vegetarians are covered too, thanks to a full vegetarian menu.
Weekend visitors can stop by for lunch, since doors open at 11:30 AM on Saturday and Sunday. Weeknight dinners start at 4 PM, but Tuesday and Wednesday are closed days.
Friday and Saturday evenings get lively, so a dinner reservation is a smart idea. Mornings on the weekend tend to be calmer if you like an easy start.
Small plates make sharing simple, and dessert gives you a sweet reason to linger. Pair it with a walk around Barnegat Light, and your afternoon pretty much plans itself.
Address: 404 Broadway, Barnegat Light, NJ 08006
3. Wally’s
Crab benedict for breakfast and shrimp tacos by dinner? One kitchen in Surf City handles both without breaking a sweat.
This time-tested fixture serves American comfort food from 8 AM to 8 PM, seven days a week. That schedule makes it one of the easiest stops to slot into a busy beach weekend.
The location is hard to beat. It sits one block from the ocean, right in the heart of Surf City.
Menu highlights include swordfish, crab benedict, and fresh shrimp tacos. Presentation gets real effort, so your plate looks as good as it tastes.
Here’s a nice surprise for plant-based eaters. The restaurant offers a full vegan menu along with a full vegetarian one.
Coffee and tea fans will feel right at home, since both drinks are highlights. A slow breakfast with a good mug might become your favorite beach ritual.
You can sit inside the casual dining room or grab a seat in the large outdoor area. Dogs are allowed outside, so your four-legged travel buddy can tag along.
Reservations aren’t accepted, so plan on showing up and rolling with it. Midweek mornings and afternoons are usually the quietest windows.
Kids get their own menu, and high chairs are available. With fair prices and a creative lineup, this spot works for nearly any crew that rolls into town hungry.
Address: 712 Long Beach Blvd, Surf City, NJ 08008
4. Buckalew’s Restaurant & Tavern
Back in 1874, this building started life as a hotel. Today it feeds Beach Haven from a porch that has plenty of stories behind it.
That history gives Buckalew’s a character you can’t fake. Beach Haven itself is a historic resort community, and this place fits the town’s long memory beautifully.
The menu covers a lot of ground. Seafood and steaks lead the way, while sushi, sandwiches, and burgers keep picky eaters happy.
Portions run generous, so splitting a plate is a reasonable strategy. Small plates and comfort food round out the options when you just want a snack.
Unlike some seasonal shore spots, this one is open all year. That makes it a great backup plan for an off-season New Jersey getaway.
Live music fills the room on weekends, adding a bit of energy to dinner. A fireplace offers a snug spot when the ocean air turns chilly.
You can choose indoor seating or the pleasant outdoor porch. Dogs are welcome outside, which is a bonus for traveling pet owners.
Doors open at 11 AM daily, and kitchens stay busy into the evening. Reservations aren’t taken, so mornings and early afternoons are usually calmer.
Kids have their own menu and high chairs. Grab a seat on that old porch, and you’re eating somewhere that has watched the island change for over a century.
Address: 101 N Bay Ave, Beach Haven, NJ 08008
5. The Arlington
Crispy chicken skins as a must-try dish? Somebody in this kitchen clearly understands snacking at a whole new level.
The Arlington sits on Long Beach Boulevard in Ship Bottom, the first town you hit after crossing the bridge onto the island. Updated American fare is the specialty, with a hip, modern feel.
Seafood lovers have a lot to choose from. Crab cakes, perfectly cooked halibut, salmon, mussels, and a lobster roll all show up among the favorites.
Then there are the shore-style extras. Clam fries and shrimp and grits bring a fun mix of coastal comfort and Southern charm.
Swordfish ranks among the standout plates here. The double cheeseburger, meanwhile, is pure indulgence for anyone who needs a break from fish.
Weeknight dinners start at 4 PM, with later hours on Friday. Saturday and Sunday open at 11 AM, so you can make it a lunch stop too.
Friday and Saturday evenings draw the biggest crowds, along with a surprisingly busy Wednesday. Afternoons are typically the quieter time to slide into a table.
Parking options include a free lot and on-site spaces. That’s a real plus on a stretch of New Jersey shore where summer parking can test anyone’s patience.
Start with those chicken skins and work your way up. Your friends will want to steal a few, so maybe order two.
Address: 1302 Long Beach Blvd, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008
6. Tuckers Tavern
Sunsets get top billing at this harborside favorite, and the rooftop deck gives you front-row seats. Tuckers Tavern sits on Southwest Avenue in Beach Haven, facing the bay side of the island.
The space carries a nautical theme from top to bottom. Deck seating and a rooftop area make it easy to stretch a meal into an evening.
On the plate, creative American cooking takes the lead. Pork belly nachos, crab orzo, and a smoked Caesar salad show the kitchen likes to play.
Burger fans should look for the version made with rib eye. Fresh seafood also earns its place on the dinner menu.
Vegetarians get serious consideration here. A full vegetarian menu includes a vegan chopped salad, so meat-free diners won’t be stuck with sides.
Brunch kicks off at 10:30 AM on weekends. Weekdays start at 11:30 AM, which works nicely for a lunch break after a morning on the sand.
Friday and Saturday evenings tend to fill up fast. Dinner reservations are recommended, especially if you want that rooftop sunset.
Families will find a kids’ menu and high chairs. Dogs can join you outside, and a fireplace helps on cooler nights.
Romance, harbor views, and creative food all in one stop? That’s a pretty strong case for planning your Saturday night around this spot.
Address: 101 Southwest Ave, Beach Haven, NJ 08008
7. Raimondo’s
Lobster risotto has a way of turning a beach trip into an anniversary dinner. At Raimondo’s, it shows up alongside lobster ravioli for double the temptation.
This Ship Bottom dining room specializes in creative Italian fine dining. The menu is known for its breadth, with a long list of selections and nightly specials.
Start with the appetizers if you can. Meatballs and burrata with fried eggplant make a strong opening act.
For the main event, the Pork Chop Calabrese is a signature. Potato crusted cod and swordfish specials give seafood fans plenty to consider.
Early bird specials are part of the deal here. That’s a nice perk if you like dining before sunset and strolling afterward.
Dinner starts at 4 PM Tuesday through Sunday, and the restaurant closes on Mondays. Evenings stay busy almost every night it’s open.
Reservations are recommended and often required. Even then, a wait is common, so give yourself some cushion in the schedule.
The atmosphere leans romantic and upscale, perfect for date night. Groups do well too, which makes it a solid pick for a family celebration.
Leave room for dessert and a cup of coffee, both known strengths. You’ll walk out talking about the risotto, and probably planning your next New Jersey shore weekend.
Address: 1101 Long Beach Blvd, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008
8. Black Whale Bar & Fish House
The day’s catch calls the shots at this fish house, and lobster usually steals the spotlight. Black Whale keeps things unfussy so the seafood can do the talking.
You’ll find it on North Pennsylvania Avenue in Beach Haven. It’s the kind of beach town restaurant that feels made for sandy flip-flops and big appetites.
Portions are generous, and the food is fresh. Complimentary appetizers add a fun bonus before your main plate even arrives.
Beyond the seafood, comfort food and small plates keep the menu flexible. Dessert is a highlight, so plan a little room for something sweet.
Hours stretch late, which helps on long summer days. Weekdays open at 3 PM, weekends open at noon, and the kitchen serves late-night food.
That flexibility is handy after a sunset walk or a late drive down the parkway. Few spots on the island keep serving this deep into the evening.
Expect a crowd, especially Thursday through Saturday evenings and on Tuesdays. Reservations are recommended, and waits are common.
Families are welcome, with a kids’ menu and high chairs ready. Dogs can hang out with you in outdoor areas.
Street parking is free, so a short stroll may be part of the plan. Friendly staff and steady cooking make this a dependable anchor for your Beach Haven night.
Address: 100 N Pennsylvania Ave, Beach Haven, NJ 08008
9. The Gables Historic Inn & Restaurant
Piano music, antiques, and a three-course dinner inside a Victorian inn sound like a scene from another century. In Beach Haven, it’s simply Thursday night.
The Gables operates as an upscale bed and breakfast with an elegant restaurant inside. Polished, antique-filled rooms set the tone before your first bite.
Dinner follows a curated three-course format. That structure turns the meal into an evening, not a quick refuel between beach sessions.
Menu highlights include grilled Spanish octopus and a grilled Berkshire pork chop. A bone-in filet mignon also earns strong praise.
Dessert might be the grand finale you remember most. The Pecan Pie Cheesecake sounds like two holiday favorites decided to team up.
Outdoor dining is a standout feature here. Eating under the open sky beside a historic building feels pretty special on a summer evening.
The restaurant serves dinner Thursday through Sunday, from 5 PM to 9 PM. Monday through Wednesday, the dining room is closed.
Reservations are recommended and often required. Plan ahead, especially for a weekend, since seating is limited by the inn’s intimate size.
A full vegetarian menu means plant-focused diners can enjoy the experience too. Tea and coffee are highlights, so linger a little after dessert and enjoy the piano.
Address: 212 Centre St, Beach Haven, NJ 08008
10. Scojo’s Eatery
Lemon ricotta pancakes are the kind of breakfast that makes waking up early on vacation feel worth it. Scojo’s Eatery serves them in Surf City from 8 AM until 2 PM daily.
This longtime family-owned spot focuses on hearty American breakfast and lunch. The space is informal, so nobody cares if you show up with sandy feet.
Steak and eggs bring serious fuel for a long beach day. Turkey dinners also make an appearance, which feels like a little holiday in July.
Portions run large, and prices stay friendly. That combination makes it a smart pick for families feeding a hungry crowd.
The interior was recently remodeled, giving the dining room a fresh look. Outdoor seating offers another option when the weather cooperates.
Kids have their own menu, and high chairs are ready. Dogs are welcome outside, so the whole family can come along.
Parking can be tricky to find, so allow a few extra minutes. Saturday mornings and Monday mornings tend to be the busiest.
Here’s a helpful surprise for a breakfast place: reservations are accepted. That can save your group from standing around while the coffee calls your name.
Speaking of coffee, it’s a highlight here, along with tea and dessert. Grab a plate of pancakes and let Surf City wake up around you.
Address: 307 Long Beach Blvd, Surf City, NJ 08008
11. Daddy O Restaurant Hotel Bar
French onion gnocchi might be the most comforting mashup on the whole island. It shows up at Daddy O, a boutique hotel with a contemporary restaurant just a short walk from the beach.
The address sits in the Brant Beach section of Long Beach Township. That central spot makes it easy to reach from either end of the island.
Rooftop seating gives the restaurant real buzz. Eating up top adds a fresh perspective to a classic shore afternoon.
Truffle fries pair nicely with the gnocchi if you’re sharing. Seafood dishes also rank high, so coastal cravings are well covered.
Families get solid choices too. The kids’ options earn plenty of praise, and high chairs are available.
Plant-based travelers have both a full vegan menu and a full vegetarian menu. That’s a big plus when dietary needs vary across your group.
Weekend brunch starts at 10:30 AM, while weekdays open at 11:30 AM. Late-night food is also offered, which helps after an evening stroll.
Friday and Saturday evenings bring the biggest crowds. Dinner reservations are recommended, especially if you’re aiming for the rooftop.
Live music and a fireplace add extra charm depending on the season. Stay the night upstairs, and your New Jersey weekend gets a lot simpler.
Address: 4401 Long Beach Blvd, Long Beach, NJ 08008
12. Delaware Avenue Oyster House & Bar
Oysters on ice, clams on the half shell, and a long counter built for slurping. This raw bar in Beach Haven makes a perfect finale for a weekend of shore eating.
Delaware Avenue Oyster House is family-owned and sits along Long Beach Boulevard. The room carries a fun, classy nautical theme.
Local oysters are a major draw. Look for the Sunkissed Salt Oysters, a menu highlight with a name that sounds like summer.
Peel-and-eat shrimp and fried calamari keep the snacking going. A bowl of clam chowder adds comfort if the evening turns breezy.
Golden Mussels round out the list of standouts. Seafood entrees cover heartier appetites beyond the raw bar.
Afternoon specials on oysters, clams, and shrimp make the early evening a popular time. Wednesday through Saturday evenings are the busiest stretch.
Weekday hours start at 4 PM, while weekends open at noon. That gives you a great lunch option on Saturday or Sunday.
Reservations aren’t taken, and street parking can be tough. Arriving a bit early helps you snag a seat at that long counter.
Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are welcome outside. The space is also known as LGBTQ+ friendly, so everyone can pull up a stool and grab an oyster.
Address: 13211 Long Beach Blvd, Beach Haven, NJ 08008
Share this story
